Hearthpwn

WTB feedback for feedback

Communisme is a joke card. I know the wording is wrong, but it feels better. Also, i apologise in advance if it offends anyone.

Quote from CheeseEtc >>

Alright, here's what I have in my folders:

As usual, here's the rest of my shit : https://imgur.com/a/safe2

To be honest none of my cards looks good enough to be submitted to me.

 

Quote from Dr_Scaphandre >>

Here's my idea for now. I'll make more later.

(Ignore the Battlecry keyword. I fucked that up and will remove it later. The battlecry doesn't exist, it's a passive effect.)

 

Another one

Quote from Broeck1 >>

Quote from ThisOtherGuyTox >>

WTB feedback for feedback

Communisme is a joke card. I know the wording is wrong, but it feels better. Also, i apologise in advance if it offends anyone.

 

Are we going to have the same idea again? XD I got this from the expansion comp. Not sure I'll go for it tho. As for your card, I think its really cute. The option that will always be chosen is Moonfire tho. No one will ever pick Wisp.

Hey all. This was first a paladin card but i always thought it should have been neutral. I've been waiting until it was viable again so here's the opportunity.  

Khaz'goroth is one of the Titans who are responsible for creating the Dragon Aspects. Lore-wise, Khaz'goroth is Deathwing's creator, and he's known as the Craftsman hence (although it's inaccurate in detail) the reason i chose him to interact with all the Aspects. I'm trying to make Dragon archetype playable for all classes and especially make the lesser played Aspects viable. 

The idea is Khaz'goroth alters your deck to the degree you chose - Add 6 Aspects (2 Deathwings) to your deck then add 6 Runes, add 3 Aspects add 3 runes. Each Aspect weakens your early game and draw rng, but they generally improve your swing turn, comeback potential.

So, I've not changed the Runes to neutral yet (still pala) as I've prob overpowered some atm given that rogue/mage can now use them and will need to redo them anyway (Malygos's Spell-Weaver should prob read 'this turn' for example).

Wyrm-Runes: (not wyrm-seals)

Any advise is appreciated.

Making freeze shaman a thing has been my passion since KotFT ... without success. Therefore ...

I think i'll go with a variation of a previous creation i made (for 6.17 i think)

And another one, art and name not finalised yet

Vero cool! And very on the WC lore! I love it :) You are a talented person indeed :)

Cheers  :)

Quote from nurgling13 >>

Quote from CheeseEtc >>

Alright, here's what I have in my folders:

As usual, here's the rest of my shit : https://imgur.com/a/safe2

To be honest none of my cards looks good enough to be submitted to me.

Man, not another Rager card! I like Experiment with Fire, but I feel like I've seen it before (maybe you posted it awhile ago or something). I also feel like it would be better attached to a minion. Warp Splinter is not a very good idea, I think. It's probably terrible in constructed and super good in Arena.

Quote from ThisOtherGuyTox >>

WTB feedback for feedback

Communisme is a joke card. I know the wording is wrong, but it feels better. Also, i apologise in advance if it offends anyone.

Ultrasaur isn't very good, so Ultramancer is also not very good. This is just way too slow of a card. I'll pass on the joke card. I like Owlkin Hatchling. I don't think the wording is right, though. You can't break up the sentence that way with the semicolon. You have X A or B Y, but X and Y both need to be on the same side of the semicolon. I think it would be better if you did "Gain a copy of Moonfire; or a Wisp", or "Add a Wisp to your hand; or a copy of Moonfire to your hand."

Quote from Broeck1 >>

Quote from ThisOtherGuyTox >>

WTB feedback for feedback

Communisme is a joke card. I know the wording is wrong, but it feels better. Also, i apologise in advance if it offends anyone.

 

Are we going to have the same idea again? XD I got this from the expansion comp. Not sure I'll go for it tho. As for your card, I think its really cute. The option that will always be chosen is Moonfire tho. No one will ever pick Wisp.

This doesn't really seem balanced. Getting 2 spell damage is really good. Evolved Kobold and Spellweaver both show this is worth quite a bit of mana. Your card is well over that power level. 

Quote from nurgling13 >>

Here are my ideas so far:

The librarian isn't that big a threat, but, played at the right time, it can make your opponent choose between giving you a free Silence and making a suboptimal play. The other two are sources of Sap for Rogues. The first one is symmetric with your opponent, but would be really good in mill where they really don't want you to be able to play your minions again. The last one is simpler and punny. Also, he's covering his face so that you can't see him. He thinks that's how you Stealth. He just wants to be a Rogue!

 

Quote from CheeseEtc >>

 

@Prod: Doom Knight is OP as fuck and has no flavor. The second card is too bland.

Quote from CheeseEtc >>

I

ndividual reviews while I can manage it:

@Demonxz95: Shadowform synergies are overdone. What Shadow Priest needs to even see the light of the day is alternative ways to switch to shadowform, not terribly-slow shadowform synergies. Update page 2: The other cards aren't really interesting.

@Teknican: I like this card from a gameplay point of view but it's not eye-catching. Would still upvote. Update page 2: Well, I don't like any of these though.

@Linkblade91: It's not particularily interesting or flavorful. Update page 2: Volcanic Elemental looks cool though. Would upvote that one.

@Linkfan001: It's not particularily interesting or flavorful.

@fffinderous: Too complicated and I don't see the unifying logic behind all these effects. Update page 3: Also too bland

@HenryXLIII: I'm probably missing a pop culture reference here but gameplay-wise this card would be absolute cancer. Transforming an early game 1/1 into a 5/4 with Taunt is OP as fuck. It needs to cost 4 or even 5.

@Ozymandias: Interesting, I can see this being played at least in arena. Would upvote.

@Vilegloom: Dark Merchant Tofu is my favorite. It might make an underexplored Rogue archetype viable. Would upvote.

@GameTheory345: The effect is not very interesting and I don't get the flavor. Also don't post your card as an attachment because most people won't bother clicking on it.

@Zanywoop: The effect is far-fetched and I don't like it. Besides we already had 2 Ner'zhuls who won a comp and we don't need more.

@Shatterstar1998: None of them are interesting to me. Matthias Shaw would be absolute cancer in most Rogue decks.

@Zukuu: No Mech tag. 0/10

@Cogito_ergo_sum: As I said, Trick or Treat is super flavorful and has good chances to win. Doomedguard is also cool flavor-wise but it sucks gameplay-wise.

@Dr_Scaphandre: No pirate decks would ever play a minion that costs 6. Also the effect is too bland.

@nurgling13: Stormwind Librarian is by far my favorite. It's very flavorful and very useful for Machine Gun Priest. Would upvote. The art sucks though, there must be a WoW-related artwork of a librarian somewhere on the Internet.

@StegosaurusRex: I don't really see the use of this and the card has no flavor.

@biggerbossman: The base concept is too bland.

@Wailor: This would actually need to have above vanilla stats, not below. Restoring 10 Health to your hero in a convoluted way is not worth summoning two 2/3 bodies for your opponent. Also thanks for feedback.

@_Envy_: wtf man. Update page 4: Decaying Wanderer is a good effect but it needs to be given Warcraft flavor!

@Heinibrother: Pandaren Classes is very funny, but too random to actually see play. Similarily I don't see why anybody would use Patches' First mate.

@Lathy: Base concept is too boring.

@rjcv: The card could as well say "Battlecry: Your opponent gains control of your minions". The wording is clearly just a way to fit the theme so it's not good. Even without this issue, the card is not original.

@MarioToast: It's too good. Even then, the base concept is not very original or flavorful.

@Tox: I like Owlkin Hatchling but it's too good, particularily in Malygos Druid. Ultrasaur is an average card, I would rate it 7/14 *ba dum tss*. Why did you use the French wording for "Communisme"? ARE YOU TRYING TO IMPLY SOMETHING ???? Update: Dreamer of Royalty is super weird. And are you serious when you say you like Doom Shredder? I originally did this as a troll card XD.

@WURBEURUGUREUG???: The effect is weird and makes no sense. It's clearly a card made just to fit the restrictions.

@hereehharhehre???: This is waaay too complicated. I didn't even read all the runes and I doubt anybody will. Also Khaz'Goroth is a Titan, it's unadapted as a minion.

@Tamiras12: This is too bland. Also 'Frozen' needs to have a capitalized.

@Prod: Doom Knight is OP as fuck and has no flavor. The second card is too bland.