Hearthpwn

Great Idea Razor. That makes me think of something

How about this one ? Does it need to be more balanced or it's already good ?

Quote from ThisOtherGuyTox >>

Quote from Don_Dingle >>

This week's theme is pretty interesting. Since there isn't a hard rule as to what a Common minion should be, only time will tell if people will actively vote for the ones that feel the most Common-ish. I think most of these can arguably be classified as Commons, except maybe for Dawnchaser. Would love to hear anyone's thoughts on them.

 

 

 You're only allowed to put 3 cards at once, according to the rules.

Devoted Occulist is a pretty cool idea. Although i'd argue the wording is wrong. The current wording indicates that they die immdiatly when you play this, which i believe is not the case.

You may have to refrain from using the "Horribly" wording, to make this fit under 4 lines. This would allow for the wording "Battlecry: Give adjacent minions +4/+4 until end of turn. Then they die.

 

Quote from Demonxz95 >>

Quote from Don_Dingle >>

This week's theme is pretty interesting. Since there isn't a hard rule as to what a Common minion should be, only time will tell if people will actively vote for the ones that feel the most Common-ish. I think most of these can arguably be classified as Commons, except maybe for Dawnchaser. Would love to hear anyone's thoughts on them.

 

You forgot the Elemental tag on Lightmom (Lightspawn has the Elemental tag) and I don't like that it's literally the same art just colored differently.

Dawnchaser could probably just say "At the end of your turn, gain Divine Shield" as that's pretty much the same thing and the wording would be better.

Mechasaur should probably have a wording change. I understand what you were going for, but the text would be better and easier to understand if it said "Can only attack minions with Taunt and heroes" or "Can only attack heroes and Taunt minions".

Druid of the Club is a bit confusing. What exactly does it do?

The other two are fine as they are.

 

Quote from kegstandgoldmedalist >>

Quote from Don_Dingle >>

This week's theme is pretty interesting. Since there isn't a hard rule as to what a Common minion should be, only time will tell if people will actively vote for the ones that feel the most Common-ish. I think most of these can arguably be classified as Commons, except maybe for Dawnchaser. Would love to hear anyone's thoughts on them.

 

 

If you don't mind, I'll just comment on the cards I like/would consider upvoting.

Devoted Occultist. Well done on the 7-mana 4/4 meme. Fits in warlock and feels fair, since you have to think about positioning, not to mention the two-minion requirement (of course, rarely a problem for warlock). I also like how you inverted the sac-lock theme. Tempting to classify it as rare (see Void Terror, sorta) but I think it's acceptable.

Dawnchaser. I think I would word it as "At the end of your turn, gain Divine Shield." The bigger problem is that I agree with you: This card feels solidly Rare. I would hang onto though. Personally I think it's a nice card.

 

Quote from Dr_Scaphandre >>

Quote from Don_Dingle >>

This week's theme is pretty interesting. Since there isn't a hard rule as to what a Common minion should be, only time will tell if people will actively vote for the ones that feel the most Common-ish. I think most of these can arguably be classified as Commons, except maybe for Dawnchaser. Would love to hear anyone's thoughts on them.

 

Devoted Occultist: Now does the Occultist itself die horribly, or does the minions it buffs do? Either way, dust it. It's a worse Bonemare.

Lightmom: Okay now you're memeing. Even as a serious submission it's a dust since Silence Priest is a thing

Dawnchaser: Now this is a good idea, and good balanced stats. My only quorum is I don't know if it should be a rare instead or not.

Mechasaur: Dust. 7 mana 8/8 that can't attack when Swamp King Dred is a 7 9/9 that can is fucking garbage

Storm Elemental: Now this is a good card. I think this should be your submission. This is the most exciting to me. Great for control Shaman.

Druid of the Club: This should've been a Choose One card. Get rid of the RNG and just make it a Choose One effect.

 

Quote from BGgungame >>

Quote from Shatterstar1998 >>

Repost my cards:

 The shaman one I think is balanced, it might even be a little weak.

The rogue one...Do you really think this effect would be found on a common card? Honestly? Violet Teacher

Quote from FlashCam >>

How about this one ? Does it need to be more balanced or it's already good ?

Quote from MrPaatero >>

Quote from FlashCam >>

How about this one ? Does it need to be more balanced or it's already good ?

 Furious Avenger + 2x cold blood = 10 mana 3 cards 30damage OTK. Even with only one cold blood it would still be 20 damage with only 2 cards. Charge and Windfury is a problematic combination especially with neutral minions because you have to remember all classes OTK options.

If this costed 10 mana then it would be ok (Rogues still can OTK with Preps and Coins but it is much more difficult). Another option is to make this a class-specific card for a class that doesn't have minion-based OTK options (such as Mage) and maybe change it 4/5.

 

 

 

Quote from Dr_Scaphandre >>

Reposting my cards. I know I'm gonna use Flying Witch, though I don't know which statline to use. Which witch is better and more balanced?

 

Quote from Lathy >>

Three new ideas. Not the ebst, not the worst:

 

Quote from Demonxz95 >>

So far, I feel like my best bet and what I'll go with is Blast Goblin unless I think of something better.

 

Quote from RazorOfArtorias >>

First idea!

 

Quote from ThisOtherGuyTox >>

Great Idea Razor. That makes me think of something

 

Quote from FlashCam >>

How about this one ? Does it need to be more balanced or it's already good ?

 

Shameless bump of my Paladin card, but I also have a silly extra one for your consideration :)

• "Does the Light hand out cookies? No? 'What have you done for me lately?'"
• C'Thun has been reconsidering his "open door" recruiting policy.

Quote from BorkBot >>

Quote from Demonxz95 >>

So I have a new card, where once again, my inability to name anything strikes me.

 I'd call it Tenacious Fiend or something like that. Seems like a nice card to me.

Quote from Demonxz95 >>

 

 

Not gonna lie, C'Thun's Rage(r) could probably be 3 mana like a regular Rager and it would still be balanced and not in any way problematic. At 7 mana, it's just WWWWAAAAAYYYYYY too expensive to be practical. I get that it's supposed to be a joke card, but joke cards can still be perfectly balanced like a normal card. It's pretty funny though.

Quote from Lathy >>

Cheers!

Let's see. Hex is worth 3-4 mana (let us say 3,5). The aim is a 4,5 mana minion then (given the cost of 8 of your card), which means 5/5. Any higher, and it's too good. A 4/5 might even seem more reasonable, as a body combined with a spell tend to be 0,5-1 mana below their combined cost (let's not look at Bonemare, but cards more like Corpse Raiser).

Quote from Lathy >>

Three new ideas. Not the ebst, not the worst:

Quote from kegstandgoldmedalist >>

Scrapped all but one of my original ideas, tweaked the remaining card, and added two new ideas.

Tweaked Fire-Charged Firecharger based on The Progenitor's comment. Also made him a little beefier at the expense of Shadow Word: Pain vulnerability. Compare to Malygos, and I think it's definitely balanced. Feeling a little unsure about the art, though, since I can't think of any "big" goblin cards in HS. I also considered a stacking Spell Damage effect, like Gurubashi Berserker, which I would imagine would be fine considering it's a basic card.

The other two are tests to see if their flavor is worth submitting. Raging Bull is my clear-cut Timmy card.

Quote from linkblade91 >>

Quote from Lathy >>

Three new ideas. Not the ebst, not the worst:

 I will echo the sentiment that I like Scarlet Kennelmaster the most.

Quote from CheeseEtc >>

 Bump this again before posting to have maximum feedback.