Hearthpwn

Why did my card not make it despite having as many votes as Jade Golem, Azure Whelping and Hatchling?

How the hell did I get third!?

Not that I'm going to complain about though. I find Jade Golem hilarious and also quite clever. I also really like Azure Whelping and Banana Handler.

Quote from ShadowsOfSense >>

 Hearthcards :(

Quote from ThisOtherGuyTox >>

Wait...

People voted for Vilecat?

It is not even a beast!

Jade Golem isn't functional. It doesn't make sense for it to be a collectible minion. The correct way to make this card would be for it to be a spell that summoned a Jade Golem. Setting the Health and Attack of the Jade Golem to 1 is contradictory to its functionality. So, Jade Golem should have been disqualified. If you make the assumption that the Health and Attack scale as you summon Jade Golems, well, then it isn't a 1/1 minion, is it? 

Quote from CecilHoshino >>

See, I interpreted Jade Golem as a joke card, hence my not voting for it as a sort of "Smart alec..." response.

@TheWizardM - What cat? I didn't submit a cat. Do you mean kegstand's Dupl-icat?

@Zukuu - Was Imgur down for you, personally, this go around? Because that's actually happened to me, once

I voted for Banana Handler, Black Cat, and my own card. I'd also have voted for Vilecat if it was actually a beast :P

How the heck did my Black Cat make it?!

Anyways, I'm voting for Vilecat, Banana Handler (changed my mind about this one), and Mana Wisp.

Quote from TheWizardM >>

I agree, it's a pretty tight design space, especially considering the relatively aggressive meta of hearthstone (compared to other card games).

I would've voted for @CecilHoshino 's cat if it made it to the poll (and if he hadn't changed it into a powered down version of Firefly.

My votes go to; Vilecat for it's simple yet interesting mechanic (I like how it's almost a weapon but not quite), and Mana Wisp, because it's simple and I like wisps.

Cards I think are a bit overloaded and/or overpowered; Chrominius,  Azure Whelpling, Druid of the Night.
Chrominius gives you not only a good amount of card draw, but also a way to scout, and a sort of guarantee on the card quality of the draws; if it's a too high mana cost, neither you nor your opponent can play the card.
Azure Whelpling is a better version of On the Hunt, due to it's flexibility as a burst damage card (due to Brann Bronzebeard synergy).
Druid of the night is a bit on the strong side.

Black cat and frogg-saron seem a bit clunky to me; black cat just draws a dead card most of the time, while frogg-saron will most likely cast a random Spare Part on either itself (making it basicly a textless 1-2/1-2) or on whatver minion your opponent played the turn before. 

Jade Golem is just a weaker Jade Idol

I won't go into much detail on the other cards.