Hearthpwn

A reason to play magma rager. 

Okay. Well crasy just said it's underpowered, I'd go in the complete other direction. In an Elemental heavy meta this would be literally one of the strongest cards in the entire game. Actually imagine a situation wherein both players are playing this and it's an Elemental v Elemental deck... the game would never end.

It's also a neutral spell which doesn't exist.

Quote from crasyherbz >>

More Reviews cos I have nothing better to do at the moment.

Atash, Lesser Elemental: I like this design and it wouldn't surprise me if blizzard creates a card like this. Tokens like this are needed for many of the other elemental effects. It doesn't seem like a legendary and I'd prob make it a 2/4 or something.

 

Hello, this is my first creation for Weekly Card Design Competition 5.12.

Behold the ultimate defense: Umibozu, Keeper of Maelstrom.

You play this minion with Coin, Innervate or waiting that your opponent play 10 minions.

I think it's too strong if instead of "played" there was "summon". What do you think? The mana cost of 11 is to represent a disadvantage to play directly from the hand.

.

Alright 3 ideas so far, got a fourth I just need to work on the tokens for it. Not sure any of them are exciting enough frankly. Would appreciate the feedback.

Quote from DyingAtheist >>

Okay. Well crasy just said it's underpowered, I'd go in the complete other direction. In an Elemental heavy meta this would be literally one of the strongest cards in the entire game. Actually imagine a situation wherein both players are playing this and it's an Elemental v Elemental deck... the game would never end.

It's also a neutral spell which doesn't exist.

Quote from Nimehte >>

Quote from DyingAtheist >>

Okay. Well crasy just said it's underpowered, I'd go in the complete other direction. In an Elemental heavy meta this would be literally one of the strongest cards in the entire game. Actually imagine a situation wherein both players are playing this and it's an Elemental v Elemental deck... the game would never end.

It's also a neutral spell which doesn't exist.

 

Thanks for your review's guys I didn't want to make it a direct win for player so my concern made it a little bit under powered. I am still thinking about how to make it quest but I have another idea now. 

What if it destroys whole board like Twisting Nether for 9 mana and than generates Goblet depends on how many elemental is destroyed I think this would be a mage spell but I couldn't decide which class it would fit the most.

Quote from DyingAtheist >>

Alright 3 ideas so far, got a fourth I just need to work on the tokens for it. Not sure any of them are exciting enough frankly. Would appreciate the feedback.

Did some improvment :

   ->   

Now the minion is a Legendary one and Volcanus effect is more interesting than the previous one. Consider he'll deal at least 7 damage when transformation is effective and he'll help you clean the enemy bord at the end of your turn (Ragnaros the Firelord and C'Thun effects combined). You can also take advantage of Volcanus with Primal Fusion, Flametongue Totem, Windfury, Rockbiter Weapon, or Bloodlust.

Quote from Co_Ga >>

Did some improvment :

   ->   

Now the minion is a Legendary one and Volcanus effect is more interesting than the previous one. Consider he'll deal at least 7 damage when transformation is effective and he'll help you clean the enemy bord at the end of your turn (Ragnaros the Firelord and C'Thun effects combined). You can also take advantage of Volcanus with Primal Fusion, Flametongue Totem, Windfury, Rockbiter Weapon, or Bloodlust.

Well The Wind Shifts is based on Evolve, which is assumedly whatever that other person all based their card on. Don't see any trouble with aping an existing in-game card in pretty much every way (but that simplicity is why I wouldn't choose it)

For Scorched Earth I'm going to work on an effect sort of like Nozdormu does. Don't want to get too on board with all the Nether Portal stuff just because right now that's a very questy thing.

Quote from Co_Ga >>

Did some improvment :

   ->   

Now the minion is a Legendary one and Volcanus effect is more interesting than the previous one. Consider he'll deal at least 7 damage when transformation is effective and he'll help you clean the enemy bord at the end of your turn (Ragnaros the Firelord and C'Thun effects combined). You can also take advantage of Volcanus with Primal Fusion, Flametongue Totem, Windfury, Rockbiter Weapon, or Bloodlust.

Jaina is crazy crazy overpowered in my opinion. Like, insanely overpowered. If her battlecry was just to summon a single Water Elemental she'd still be strong, but potentially getting 2-3? Waaaaaay too strong.

Not sure on Morchok. Definitely better balanced than Jaina. 

Quote from HitSlender >>

Quote from Tusina >>

Quote from HitSlender >>

These are my ideas so far. Thoughts?

 

 

I like Atash, Lesser Elemental. It is powerful enabler for elemental synergies. 3/4 and two 1/2 taunts for 5 mana is reasonable and if you don't get Elemental synergy going, it's only 3/4 for 3 and that's reasonable.

 

Any thoughts about my entry?

 

 Thanks for reviewing my card. For your card, it's a neat idea, but I feel like it's too weak. Maybe give it +1/+2, because your losing lots of tempo, and it's a Legendary.

 So you mean like this? bec

Quote from SvagoCorp >>

My last two entries:

Just a neat twist on my very first idea. Mage doesn't have a viable Miracle deck right now, so it's very reasonable. It would be broken as a neutral.

 The closest I could go at an Elemental that fits this mechanic. Dropped its cost to 8 so a Mage can Fireblast it at turn 10 and gain at least a Rune if it's hard removed by the opponent. Not a neutral cause it would be OP in Miracle Druid and Miracle Rogue.

Who's the most upvote-worthy?

Quote from DyingAtheist >>

Quote from Co_Ga >>

Did some improvment :

   ->   

Now the minion is a Legendary one and Volcanus effect is more interesting than the previous one. Consider he'll deal at least 7 damage when transformation is effective and he'll help you clean the enemy bord at the end of your turn (Ragnaros the Firelord and C'Thun effects combined). You can also take advantage of Volcanus with Primal Fusion, Flametongue Totem, Windfury, Rockbiter Weapon, or Bloodlust.

 The only thing I'd suggest is maybe the naming of the Acolyte. Legendaries tend to be named minions whereas Scorching Acolyte sounds like any old Elemental. Realise he summons the named minion, but if you look at Voltron he's summoned by Mimirion 

Quote from Tusina >>

Quote from HitSlender >>

Quote from Tusina >>

Quote from HitSlender >>

These are my ideas so far. Thoughts?

 

 

I like Atash, Lesser Elemental. It is powerful enabler for elemental synergies. 3/4 and two 1/2 taunts for 5 mana is reasonable and if you don't get Elemental synergy going, it's only 3/4 for 3 and that's reasonable.

 

Any thoughts about my entry?

 

 Thanks for reviewing my card. For your card, it's a neat idea, but I feel like it's too weak. Maybe give it +1/+2, because your losing lots of tempo, and it's a Legendary.

 So you mean like this? bec

Most of the time you want to keep it Stealthed anyway for value, but this would allow you choose and let it survive some nontargeting damage. I made it legendary and used play instead of summon, because I really didn't want to make another prenerf [Starving Buzzard combo enabler, but rather slower longterm value engine and elemental mechanic enabler and that's why it has Stealth. Would this 1/3 version be too strong? Starving Buzzard didn't have stealth, but it was 2/2 and triggered from summon.