Hearthpwn

Amani Witch Doctor is obviously the best card, but my other favorites are Poisoned Dagger and Reinforcements. Poisoned Dagger did simple right this time. Even a vanilla weapon like this would be good in Rogue. Reinforcements is a good, new alternative to the now-Wild Muster for Battle that a number of Paladin archetypes could use now or in the future.

And, if anyone wants to know "Why didn't X card get in even though it had more votes than Y", here is my list of cards that didn't fit the theme and why:

All of these cards were probably disqualified, although you would have to ask the mods to confirm.  

Quote from nurgling13 >>

Amani Witch Doctor is obviously the best card, but my other favorites are Poisoned Dagger and Reinforcements. Poisoned Dagger did simple right this time. Even a vanilla weapon like this would be good in Rogue. Reinforcements is a good, new alternative to the now-Wild Muster for Battle that a number of Paladin archetypes could use now or in the future.

And, if anyone wants to know "Why didn't X card get in even though it had more votes than Y", here is my list of cards that didn't fit the theme and why:

Shadowmoon Dark Priestess (Gooner1122) - Costs less than Auchenai Soulpriest, so it isn't strictly worse.

Anzu (Rhadan) - Not strictly worse than Savannah Highmane, because summoning three 1/1's is not strictly worse than two 2/2's. Summoning three minions instead of two is better for cards that depend on the number of minions you have out/summoned/died (e.g., Savage Roar, Cult Master, Knife Juggler)

Enslaved Abyssal (Shatterstar1998) - This isn't strictly worse than Flamewreathed Faceless. If it dies before your next turn, then it is better to have summoned this than Flamewreated Faceless, because you'll get the destroyed mana crystals back, rather than having them locked. There are a number of other common situations where Enslaved Abyssal is better, such as with Deathrattle synergy (e.g., Baron Rivendare), cheating the card into play (e.g., Voidcaller, Barnes), and playing it while you have 10 mana.

Emerald Idol (Clansslayer98) - This is just a different effect than Jade Idol. 

Indecisive Treant (XBAT_EU) - Costs less and is a different effect than Unbound Elemental.

Blackwing Flamespawn (Spiderwilliams13) - Not worse than any existing card.

Bloatheb (Broeck1) - He even admits this is better than Loatheb if it survives more than one turn.

Happy Feast of WinterVeil ! (WhereAllLifeEnds) - More powerful effect than Evolve 

All of these cards were probably disqualified, although you would have to ask the mods to confirm.  

Quote from Shatterstar1998 >>

Quote from nurgling13 >>

Amani Witch Doctor is obviously the best card, but my other favorites are Poisoned Dagger and Reinforcements. Poisoned Dagger did simple right this time. Even a vanilla weapon like this would be good in Rogue. Reinforcements is a good, new alternative to the now-Wild Muster for Battle that a number of Paladin archetypes could use now or in the future.

And, if anyone wants to know "Why didn't X card get in even though it had more votes than Y", here is my list of cards that didn't fit the theme and why:

Shadowmoon Dark Priestess (Gooner1122) - Costs less than Auchenai Soulpriest, so it isn't strictly worse.

Anzu (Rhadan) - Not strictly worse than Savannah Highmane, because summoning three 1/1's is not strictly worse than two 2/2's. Summoning three minions instead of two is better for cards that depend on the number of minions you have out/summoned/died (e.g., Savage Roar, Cult Master, Knife Juggler)

Enslaved Abyssal (Shatterstar1998) - This isn't strictly worse than Flamewreathed Faceless. If it dies before your next turn, then it is better to have summoned this than Flamewreated Faceless, because you'll get the destroyed mana crystals back, rather than having them locked. There are a number of other common situations where Enslaved Abyssal is better, such as with Deathrattle synergy (e.g., Baron Rivendare), cheating the card into play (e.g., Voidcaller, Barnes), and playing it while you have 10 mana.

Emerald Idol (Clansslayer98) - This is just a different effect than Jade Idol. 

Indecisive Treant (XBAT_EU) - Costs less and is a different effect than Unbound Elemental.

Blackwing Flamespawn (Spiderwilliams13) - Not worse than any existing card.

Bloatheb (Broeck1) - He even admits this is better than Loatheb if it survives more than one turn.

Happy Feast of WinterVeil ! (WhereAllLifeEnds) - More powerful effect than Evolve 

All of these cards were probably disqualified, although you would have to ask the mods to confirm.  

 Even though you made a mistake when said Enslaved Abyssal can be cheated into play by Voidcaller (I specifically dropped the Demon tag from the card to not broke every Wild game), I'm kind of glad that my card didn't make into the round considering the fact that its effect is so swingy when activate right but so punishing when your opponent hard remove it (Sap, Polymorph, Hex) that it wouldn't be no fun for both side involve. Well, at least I have the people's voice.

Side note: I knew that I should have gone with Rogue Quest (http://i.imgur.com/fAKqXa1.png) but the Abyssal is just too fun to not show anyone else.

Ant that concludes this mini-competition. =)
Look forward to the next one on Monday.

I believe this is the first time a card without text has ever won a competition.

Quote from nurgling13 >>

I believe this is the first time a card without text has ever won a competition.

Quote from CustomHearthstone >>

The Poisoned Dagger card is nice but I must be the only one bothered by the fact that the Justicar Trueheart upgraded Hero Power already produces a 2/2 weapon called Poisoned Dagger. So, that oversight disqualified it from my consideration.