Hearthpwn

Quote from floodhorse >>

Quote from TheMugZ >>

So you think Piloted Shredder is op 4 drop? Twilight Guardian says it's a nice joke :)

 your wrong m8. if you look at the stats of twilight guardian its very reasonable and should even have higher stats imo (as it has a requirement). its just that higher mana cost minions have powercreeped slower than lower mana cost minions, and deathrattles are way undervaled. a 3/6, 4/5, whatever you want with a small ability (e.g. taunt) should really be the norm on 4-drops, just as 2/3, 3/2, with a small ability is the norm on 2 drops. twilight guardian is exactly what i just described, but even have a requirement attached to it. its not op in any way, youre wrong.

Quote from Plastikfish >>

Quote from TheMugZ >>

Quote from jainaishot >>

Quote from TheMugZ >>

So you think Piloted Shredder is op 4 drop? Twilight Guardian says it's a nice joke :)

Twilight guardian requires a specific deck to be played piloted shredder does not.Also even with the buff shredder is  35%  of the times (ok not 35% but 33% plus something, i can't recall the exact number from liquidhearth) better than 11vaule(9 stats +taunt)

So what you're saying is 67% of the time it is better to play Guardian than Shredder?.. Twilight Guardian requres specific deck to be used in, but on the other side, Shredder finds no use in dragon decks, because no matter how strong it can theoretically be, Guardian is far more reliable card.

 Nah; shredder is always a 4/3 minion that spawn a 2 mana cost creature when you put it in to the field; twilight guardian is not always a 3/6 dragon with taunt.

Therefore shredder is more reliable.

Let's put it in this prospective: you can easily put a piloted shredder in a dragon deck, but you can't put a twilight guardian in a non dragon deck.

Piloted Shredder is too auto include.  Auto include class cards fine, auto include neutrals that is a problem.  

Poor Sky Golem, he receives no love.