I tip for Leeroy, becose of how he is played just as 6 dmg to face and no other use.
And explosive trap, becose hunter have others card for clearing board and don't really need this card anymore. And it only create problematic decks, like Face hunter, which are played like rock/paper/scissors, which is not very fun to play with or against.
I could stand to see Leeroy go, but I understand a few reasons why he should stay. Mind Control Tech seems like a top candidate to me. Other than those, maybe more light-handed nerfs like Shaman recently saw.
I do not think Bloodmage Thalnos should go HoF, as he just recently came back to the meta after a long time with very limited use. He is a solid, versatile card but also a weak tempo play, which limits his use a lot, even for spell heavy decks.
DS/IF will stay with us. As above mentioned priest is still weak, and dsif doesnt have really good synergy now. Stonetusk boar will never get hofed. Your Logic is bad sorry. Quest rogue was nerfed and dr rogue not so consistent like tier 1 decks, and not the boar is the strong minion in those decks. It is just good thats all.
Btw freezing trap is not a bad call, but i think many deck types can play around it.
Leeroy will never get hofed. Than the aggro archetype lost its finisher. Why would u destroy the aggro style? Than rock paper scissor just falls apart.
And for clarification, I don't want these cards to be HoF. This is just what I think what cards are going to be HoF. I wouldn't destroy aggro because I'm mostly control player which is good against aggro.
And DS/IF combo is sometimes uninteractive and people have previously complained about it so that was my reasoning for it. It may not be good now but it will find a meta where it will be and people will start complaining again.
AGAIN, not what I want but what I think it will be.
I understood the first time that u think that not want. I just dont think these cards are good tips. But maybe i just cant call a good shot for hofing or just dont want.
But if really wanna guess imo more of a warrior/mage/shaman staple core card, which determinates the class too more. Like far sight for example.
Stonetusk boar limits design space, it's obvious. DS/IF can go too, let them be already.
I would like to see new cards in classic set, like second class legendary for everyone.
Ah that design space limiting stuff is just a not really a potential opinion sorry. Stonetusk boar is a thing whats in the collection and cheer up things when some new card maybe combo with it.
Every card which has potentional combo effect in any deck, some of us Starting this behavior.
Malygos is def a contender. I think he hasn't been HOF'd already because its the year of the dragon, bad publicity and all that. But as he's mostly an otk enabler and gets way too much value in said decks, he's been on the chopping block for a while.
Leeroy should go just because chargers like him are insane and bad for the game health wise. Or, if they DO want to keep him around, I'm a fan of the idea of nerfing the card instead so instead of "charge" he says "rush". Rush is what charge should have been from day 1 anyways.
I can see either giants Mountain or Sea rotating out depending. Both are staples for their respective play styles and can get insane values from each. Hell, mountain was even recently used in MAGE metas of all things, and mage never made use of him before the sets like Boomsday. That's how good the card is. Now weather or not they're top priority for Blizzard's rotation is another story.
And yes, it's time for the priest otk to go. Totally goes against the pries "healing" class identity and just plain broken. Time for at least one of those spells to go, probably the doubling health spell at the very least so it no longer limits design space for priest's healing effects.
This whole thread is just "old good cards must be rotated just cuz". And wow, the overuse of the "limits design space" meme.
It was a mistake for the designer to give he original classic card rotation a name, it makes it sound like it's some special category that needs to be fulfilled every year. In reality, if something is really "such a problem" or truly "has to go", they can just nerf it. I'm sure they'll fulfill the desires of the designated whiners and knock a couple out, but there hasn't been decent reasoning for any rotation at all. I especially love the idea that doing damage and winning sometimes goes against the Priest healing identity, haha. "Just plain broken", which is why priest just keeps dominating the meta with those Inner Fire decks, lol.
It depents on what they planed for the next years. Atm I have no clue to be honest. Personally I don´t think there´s any card which should get hofed. Of course if there is any card which will limit the design space of cool new designideas, I´m ok with it. But they shouldn´t put cards to hof cause of some complaining of a few people.
backstab, as it has made its way into every rogue deck since the beginning of time. Said fact aligns with Blizzards reasoning for previous hall of fames
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
To post a comment, please login or register a new account.
Stonetusk boar limits design space, it's obvious. DS/IF can go too, let them be already.
I would like to see new cards in classic set, like second class legendary for everyone.
I tip for Leeroy, becose of how he is played just as 6 dmg to face and no other use.
And explosive trap, becose hunter have others card for clearing board and don't really need this card anymore. And it only create problematic decks, like Face hunter, which are played like rock/paper/scissors, which is not very fun to play with or against.
I could stand to see Leeroy go, but I understand a few reasons why he should stay. Mind Control Tech seems like a top candidate to me. Other than those, maybe more light-handed nerfs like Shaman recently saw.
This space is intentionally blank.
MC Tech is a good choice. If not, it should be nerfed to only steal a card of up to three cost.
I do not think Bloodmage Thalnos should go HoF, as he just recently came back to the meta after a long time with very limited use. He is a solid, versatile card but also a weak tempo play, which limits his use a lot, even for spell heavy decks.
Editor of the Heartpwn Legendary Crafting Guide:
https://www.hearthpwn.com/forums/hearthstone-general/card-discussion/205920-legendary-tier-list-crafting-guide
Leeroy, MC Tech, Backstep, Zephrys...
Dranzerr#2178
Please no leeeroy
too soon tbh.
Them giants are quite usefull for zoo decks, would affect something that is used quite little nowadays. Just my rant :P
I understood the first time that u think that not want. I just dont think these cards are good tips. But maybe i just cant call a good shot for hofing or just dont want.
But if really wanna guess imo more of a warrior/mage/shaman staple core card, which determinates the class too more. Like far sight for example.
Ah that design space limiting stuff is just a not really a potential opinion sorry. Stonetusk boar is a thing whats in the collection and cheer up things when some new card maybe combo with it.
Every card which has potentional combo effect in any deck, some of us Starting this behavior.
Like combo decks have no player base...
Dont see your point, but pls correct me.
Malygos is def a contender. I think he hasn't been HOF'd already because its the year of the dragon, bad publicity and all that. But as he's mostly an otk enabler and gets way too much value in said decks, he's been on the chopping block for a while.
Leeroy should go just because chargers like him are insane and bad for the game health wise. Or, if they DO want to keep him around, I'm a fan of the idea of nerfing the card instead so instead of "charge" he says "rush". Rush is what charge should have been from day 1 anyways.
I can see either giants Mountain or Sea rotating out depending. Both are staples for their respective play styles and can get insane values from each. Hell, mountain was even recently used in MAGE metas of all things, and mage never made use of him before the sets like Boomsday. That's how good the card is. Now weather or not they're top priority for Blizzard's rotation is another story.
And yes, it's time for the priest otk to go. Totally goes against the pries "healing" class identity and just plain broken. Time for at least one of those spells to go, probably the doubling health spell at the very least so it no longer limits design space for priest's healing effects.
Just hof preperation. For a different reason ..it's useless now.
Revamp priest classic and basic set.
Like others said, Leeroy has to go! Also rotate divine spirit, sea giant, stonetusk boar and other cheap charge minions.
This whole thread is just "old good cards must be rotated just cuz". And wow, the overuse of the "limits design space" meme.
It was a mistake for the designer to give he original classic card rotation a name, it makes it sound like it's some special category that needs to be fulfilled every year. In reality, if something is really "such a problem" or truly "has to go", they can just nerf it. I'm sure they'll fulfill the desires of the designated whiners and knock a couple out, but there hasn't been decent reasoning for any rotation at all. I especially love the idea that doing damage and winning sometimes goes against the Priest healing identity, haha. "Just plain broken", which is why priest just keeps dominating the meta with those Inner Fire decks, lol.
Mind Control Tech, lol
Come on guys. . .
It depents on what they planed for the next years. Atm I have no clue to be honest. Personally I don´t think there´s any card which should get hofed. Of course if there is any card which will limit the design space of cool new designideas, I´m ok with it. But they shouldn´t put cards to hof cause of some complaining of a few people.
If they really want the game to feel fresh in April, they need to HOF many cards that we keep seeing in deck after deck.
I suggest at least:
The game can only renew itself with real change.
I would say:
Savage Roar
Swipe (!)
Scavenging Hyena
Kill Command
Frostbolt
Sorcerer's Apprentice (!)
Northshire Cleric
Divine Spirit (!)
Shadowstep (!)
Bloodlust
Flame Imp (!)
Shield Slam
Brawl
Stonetusk Boar
Acolyte of Pain
Mind Control Tech (!)
Leeroy Jenkins (!)
Sea Giant
Mountain Giant
are all the possible candidates.
I put "(!)" mark on the ones that I think those have a higher chance of getting Hall of Fame'd.
silly question, do they announce what cards are moving before actually moving them?
backstab, as it has made its way into every rogue deck since the beginning of time. Said fact aligns with Blizzards reasoning for previous hall of fames