Hearthpwn

Just had a match playing as a hunter vs. a paladin. He had the secret Eye for an Eye up and both players were at 4 health.  I deal exactly 4 damage, secret pops and the match ends as a lost for me.  

Just wondering if that means we both lost and why or if he won and again why?  I thought it would been my win since I brought his health to 0 first, kind of strange for the player to be able to resolve a spell after being dead.  I understand how Eye for an Eye works, but again, I had to deal that damage first for it to activate.

Anyway, thanks for any explanation.  

The user above is right, I'm 100% sure as I've tested this with a friend.