Hearthpwn

I think Voodoo Doll is probably only tier 1 for Mage, and then tier 3 or 4 for everyone else.

Mage already runs Polymorph, which is basically a 6 mana hard removal (4 mana + ping), so why not Voodoo Doll, too? It helps deal with the large number of threats in Spiteful Priest, and is an enabler for FLJ. I've been running two copies in ALL my mage decks (Elemental, Odd, Big Spell, and one copy for Reno in wild), and it hasn't disappointed me yet.

All other classes require an additional card in order to activate the Doll's deathrattle; and two-card combos are typically not very good (especially just for single target removal).

Moved Spectral Cutlass to tier 3.  I like the card, but being completely honest, it's a hard card to make actually work.  I'm watching Reynad's WW review right now and he makes the solid point that in order to give Cutlass value you, you need to 1) play mediocre/bad cards that generate random cards, 2) have those randomly generated cards be better plays than cards you purposely put in your deck, and/or 3) play randomly generated cards that are bad. 

Witch's Cauldron is underrated right now. I'm pretty sure some crazy Warlock control deck could make it work.

Are you kidding me? Vilespine is tier 4? That’s makes no sense. Why is it a two of in every rogue deck...? especially with shadowsteps. 

Quote from llCeler >>

Are you kidding me? Vilespine is tier 4? That’s makes no sense. Why is it a two of in every rogue deck...? especially with shadowsteps. 

Quote from Kaladin >>

 

Quote from Rumi >>

I have won every single game I have played with odd priest thanks to glitter moth replacing divine spirit for inner fire or void ripper.  Strong card.  Not tier 4.

 It is worth the trade off for running Odd Priest (instead of simply running Divine Spirit Inner Fire in a regular Priest decklist), and at what ranks and how large a sample have you "won every single game...thanks to glitter moth"?

 

vivid nightmare tier 3,  I didn't saw this card being played yet.

replace with whispering woods, the truth is not many decks (EXCEPT WARLOCK OK?) is running too much AOE the card is quite good since it's a one card board refill for hand druid I don't know how good exactly hand druid is but every time I played it, it had decent results.

I agree with your list otherwise.. it's good this time around (not like in kobolds) most epic cards are situational rather than "must have"

derp i was on mobile client and it looked like you ranked this but looking at it again I realized you wrote about it in the wanted! rating lol. my bad