Hearthpwn

"I don't think Cubelock can sacrifice anything it currently has" ummmm... N'Zoth is rotating out. Lord Godfrey would be a very good replacement considering it acts as a late game board wipe. 

I disagree with you very strongly on Lady in White. Lady in White's issue is that it is a 6 mana card that supports a Tempo Archetype. It kind of reminds me of The Mistcaller to a certain extent, where its cost and stats counteract the purpose of the deck it is trying to support. The reason Keleseth works (or at least worked) is because he is a 2 mana 2/2 that you can drop on the board early in the game. When you add cards like Oasis Snapjaw or health heavy cards that don't have much attack value, you'll have to play those cards in their unbuffed form until at LEAST turn 6. And that's if you even draw Lady in White on curve. If you don't draw her, you're basically guaranteed to lose the game. Yes, her effect is powerful, yes she has some potential, but in the deck you suggested she be featured in, she isn't that great due to her cost. 

Great way to make the morning go by quicker waiting for WW to go live.  Thanks for the in-depth review of each card.  Appreciate you putting the time to explain the reasoning behind all of your ratings, even if they turn out to be wrong, at least we know what you were thinking about at the time!

Oh, I'm sure I'll be wrong with some! Look at my KaC review and it will make you cringe, haha. Thanks for taking the time to read!!

Very wrong about some of these but hey...

Looks like Lifedrinker, Rebuke, Rat Trap and Houndmaster Shaw were right on the money.

¯\_(ツ)_/¯

Thanks again for the review!

Quote from doomr >>

While I appreciate such a well written and thorough review, I gotta say say I think most of these ratings are way off. I even cringed reading the review of Coffin Crasher. It's a good card which you gave one star, which is ok in itself, but then you compared it to Big Priest and said it isn't a viable replacement for Barnes and Y'Shaarj, Rage Unbound. That makes absolutely no sense. This goes in deathrattle/quest priest.. i'm so confused

I Guess Coffin Crasher just wasn't meant to be. It's a shame too, I wanted him to be good too. Too clunky, I guess.

:))))))))

Quote from Pageturner >>

Quote from doomr >>

While I appreciate such a well written and thorough review, I gotta say say I think most of these ratings are way off. I even cringed reading the review of Coffin Crasher. It's a good card which you gave one star, which is ok in itself, but then you compared it to Big Priest and said it isn't a viable replacement for Barnes and Y'Shaarj, Rage Unbound. That makes absolutely no sense. This goes in deathrattle/quest priest.. i'm so confused

I Guess Coffin Crasher just wasn't meant to be. It's a shame too, I wanted him to be good too. Too clunky, I guess.

:))))))))

 Coffin Crasher HAS to be good in the expansion hopfully. Until then, I can't to get more of these predictions wrong... Have you read the TWW Mage predictions? That will give you a good laugh.