Hearthpwn

Quote from dirbrian >>

Overrated, not only do you have to build a few cards around it but it shuffles into your deck rather than your hand, making it inconsistently unreliable

So good.

maybe u can build a deck like mimic pod and tistle tea around this card to prevent getting fatigued 

This is best weapon so far.
can even give rogue lifesteal.
but make no good for aggro deck.

 BTW why people are so dumb???
You just play this when you fatigue, Hero Power then this go back to deck and now you never fatigue.
YOU DON'T NEED ANY STUPID COMBO SHIT

Quote from richarq >>

Guys the card is cool but like now it is not a good card. We can't built a deck only around one card. Even worst the deathrattle effect in most of the rogue's deck is an issue not a benefit. I want see you, when you are in turn 9/10 against a priest, you are  top decking and you will draw the dagger 1 mana 1/3 how happy you will be. It is a cool card but now it is not so good. It will be good, because I think that in the next expansion Blizzard will release the second ones. (as you can see the dagger in the picture is one, but the kingslayers are two)

1.) This has no interaction with the death knight. Literal negative interaction. 

2.) You have to invest other cards into it, to make it not suck. If it gets Oozed as is, it's really bad.

3.) Even if you invest a +2 and life steal poison into it, is it all that good to draw a 3/3 weapon with life steal that cost you three cards throughout the game for this? Fine, maybe it's a 5/3 weapon if you've invested multiple poisons into it, but that's still ok. It gets better with pirate rogue, but remember you have to re-draw a one of weapon.

4.) There's only one, so whatever you sink into it, if it's deep in your deck it can honestly not matter, this will happen often :(

5.) Not only is it bad with the death knight Rogue, it's bad with the hero power too :( 

6.) It's also an awful bad top deck almost always mid to late game if not buffed. 

If you can buff it to a 5/3 with Deadly Poison / Squidface AND give it Lifesteal then it might be worth it but that is a whole lot of effort to go through and probably wouldn't be very consistent..

Quote from Gogu >>

I am sooo ready. Blade Flurry died for this. 

Quote from richarq >>

Quote from Demagogue >>

1.) This has no interaction with the death knight. Literal negative interaction. 

2.) You have to invest other cards into it, to make it not suck. If it gets Oozed as is, it's really bad.

3.) Even if you invest a +2 and life steal poison into it, is it all that good to draw a 3/3 weapon with life steal that cost you three cards throughout the game for this? Fine, maybe it's a 5/3 weapon if you've invested multiple poisons into it, but that's still ok. It gets better with pirate rogue, but remember you have to re-draw a one of weapon.

4.) There's only one, so whatever you sink into it, if it's deep in your deck it can honestly not matter, this will happen often :(

5.) Not only is it bad with the death knight Rogue, it's bad with the hero power too :( 

6.) It's also an awful bad top deck almost always mid to late game if not buffed. 

 Yes exactly. I want also add that you need a deck that is related to heavy draws. 

Quote from karnnumart >>

 BTW why people are so dumb???
You just play this when you fatigue, Hero Power then this go back to deck and now you never fatigue.
YOU DON'T NEED ANY STUPID COMBO SHIT

Quote from Horkinger >>

Quote from cluelesspug >>

Quote from Horkinger >>

1 mana 1/3 is not light‘s justice . And I don’t know whether it is worth to put in weapon buffs which presently are not played. On top of it, you have to redraw the card from your deck once it is destroyed. With forge of souls this would be great. Without, I think it is too slow. You buff it to a 5/x with lifesteal and then it dies and you need to wait 6 turns to redraw it. While you used 4 cards (weapon and 3 buffs) to create this weapon over 3 turns. It’s hard for me to imagine this works out. 

Paladin doesn't have weapon buffs. That's the difference between this and Light's Justice. Just having a 3/3 weapon on turn 2 can win you the game by itself.

But this is not a 3/3 weapon. You are talking about a two card combo on turn 2. and while it will allow you to trade face with 3 minions, the card advantage is reduced by the fact that you buff your weapon with Cards as well. In the best case, this will be amazing. Buff it and kill minions while healing yourself is great. But what will the average case be? Having Leeching Poison and Deadly Poison in hand while waiting on the single copy of the legendary weapon? Or having only leeching poison for your 1 attack weapon? I still have doubts.

Um... fun design, don't know if it's worth all the efforts to play buff weapon cards. Hopefully so.

Wild Pirate Oil Rogue

Wild Miracle Oil Rogue

Mill Rogue

I am going to insta-craft this for sure.

Quote from Nihls >>

Why do people think this weapon prevents fatigue? you can attack 3 times in every turn to destroy it and put it back into your deck? No. 

Incredibly versatile and dangerous card. I love it. It just inevitably gets out of control if you commit enough buffs to it.

Thank god there are no weapon specific draws in rogue. 

Yeah, I figured after typing my message, brain asleep... Still don't think it would make mill rogue good. With the current tools you mill your opponent but you also draw a lot.

Rummaging Kobold and you can have way more consistency around this weapon. Crazy value for a single card.

Quote from Dudu42 >>

Rummaging Kobold and you can have way more consistency around this weapon. Crazy value for a single card.

Oh good heavens. Molten Blade can become this. What do you suppose a Dead Mans Hand weapon buff warrior would do with a gem like this and Forge of Souls?