Jesus some people rate discarding a card from your deck is really really bad. Honestly this mechanic will come into HS more and more. Fel Reaver was bad because it killed you, but a 4 mana 5/5 isn't too bad, in fact this card is insane in arena and it's stronger than Yeti and Yeti would probably be run if your deck was 40-45 card big.
Devolve buff or trading into another minion on T5, those are the only two good (mind you I said good) options I see with this. I try to keep an open mind about all the cards, but unless your opponent silences it for you, you're going to burn 3 cards silencing it yourself or gifting it with Treachery. I don't vote Bad/Dust It all that often, but here we are...
In any aggro or midrange deck this is a 4 mana vanilla 5/5. I'm not quite sure if it's good enough for constructed. Maybe in token druid? It does lack a 4 drop.
But I find the poll results just as laughable as Gnomeferatu's.
Even with the new warlock card you lose 3 cards from your deck just to give a 5/5 to your opponent. This is the worst card ever! This has 0 use! What is this?
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
"... but not less than (1)" is needed now more than ever!
There are quite a few aggro or midrange decks where this downside isn't relevant, however a vanilla "4 mana: 5/5" is just not good enough for constructed. The only deck this would have real synergy in is a Jungle Giants druid, and that deck actually wants its deck so you don't fatigue instantly from the heavy card draw after playing Barnabus the Stomper.
cool card, could work... or not... Maybe in a Treachery warlock deck you will burn 3 cards to execute the combo, yes... But how many cards will your opponent play to get rid of this minion is the question.
will he target a fireball of this minion to get rid of it when it is on his side of the board ?
will he/she play less cards, because they are afraid to burn a very good/win condition card of his/her deck ? i don't know, but could be really insane when used in the right time !
I mean, I get where they are coming from but 5/5 for 4 isn't enough a bounus for it to be worth the affect. maybe if it was a 7/7 or 8/8 is would be more like Fel Reaver
The +1 attack over a Chillwind Yeti doesn't feel enough for the downside of this card. Maybe if this was a 4 mana 6/6 it would feel more okay with me, but that is crossing over Ancient Healbot in stats for 1 less mana. Could have just added another health to make it a 4 mana 5/6 or something.
This doesn't feel like a very good card for arena or constructed.
Better than people give it credit for... but not by much. Decent but probably not viable in aggro and pretty solid in arena. Honestly, it is just worse than a lot of other 4 mana minions. Maybe if it was a 5/6?
"Most believe there are two types of people who go into a crucible. The ones who become stronger from the experience and survive it, and the ones who die. But there's a third type. The ones who learn to love the fire" - Sebastian Blood
Jesus some people rate discarding a card from your deck is really really bad. Honestly this mechanic will come into HS more and more. Fel Reaver was bad because it killed you, but a 4 mana 5/5 isn't too bad, in fact this card is insane in arena and it's stronger than Yeti and Yeti would probably be run if your deck was 40-45 card big.
Unless you're playing a really slow deck its just better than Chillwind Yeti. You can basically pretend this is a vanilla 5/5.
Devolve buff or trading into another minion on T5, those are the only two good (mind you I said good) options I see with this. I try to keep an open mind about all the cards, but unless your opponent silences it for you, you're going to burn 3 cards silencing it yourself or gifting it with Treachery. I don't vote Bad/Dust It all that often, but here we are...
Can you res the discarded cards?
In any aggro or midrange deck this is a 4 mana vanilla 5/5. I'm not quite sure if it's good enough for constructed. Maybe in token druid? It does lack a 4 drop.
But I find the poll results just as laughable as Gnomeferatu's.
what a joke
i love it TREACHERY
"Follow the rules!"
Even with the new warlock card you lose 3 cards from your deck just to give a 5/5 to your opponent. This is the worst card ever! This has 0 use! What is this?
"... but not less than (1)" is needed now more than ever!
There are quite a few aggro or midrange decks where this downside isn't relevant, however a vanilla "4 mana: 5/5" is just not good enough for constructed. The only deck this would have real synergy in is a Jungle Giants druid, and that deck actually wants its deck so you don't fatigue instantly from the heavy card draw after playing Barnabus the Stomper.
cool card, could work... or not... Maybe in a Treachery warlock deck you will burn 3 cards to execute the combo, yes... But how many cards will your opponent play to get rid of this minion is the question.
will he target a fireball of this minion to get rid of it when it is on his side of the board ?
will he/she play less cards, because they are afraid to burn a very good/win condition card of his/her deck ? i don't know, but could be really insane when used in the right time !
I mean, I get where they are coming from but 5/5 for 4 isn't enough a bounus for it to be worth the affect. maybe if it was a 7/7 or 8/8 is would be more like Fel Reaver
The +1 attack over a Chillwind Yeti doesn't feel enough for the downside of this card. Maybe if this was a 4 mana 6/6 it would feel more okay with me, but that is crossing over Ancient Healbot in stats for 1 less mana. Could have just added another health to make it a 4 mana 5/6 or something.
This doesn't feel like a very good card for arena or constructed.
Crappy Fel Reaver. If it was a 6/6 it might be worth using, but it's barely giving you any benefit!
I think this card meant for warrior who can put his hand into his deck
cards in your hand all you need?
Play this card , burn your remaining deck and put your hand into your deck
now you got most powerfull 5 card in your deck good job
else? its dust in everyting else :/
This argument always fails since not every card is equal in terms of power. Removing the card you need for the situation your in makes you lose.
+1 attack over base stats for cost slot for that effect is not worth.
Not even for arena
Better than people give it credit for... but not by much. Decent but probably not viable in aggro and pretty solid in arena. Honestly, it is just worse than a lot of other 4 mana minions. Maybe if it was a 5/6?
"Most believe there are two types of people who go into a crucible. The ones who become stronger from the experience and survive it, and the ones who die. But there's a third type. The ones who learn to love the fire" - Sebastian Blood
guys stop thinking of treachery that is just bad and it's misleading the people who understand that into thinking this card is bad.
You use this in aggro or midrange and there is no downside.
That's really heavy punishment for only +1 stat...