Hearthpwn

I've been waiting to start crafting cards but I still haven't decided which decks I want to play. I played Wild before Un'Goro but I might play Standard now. I have Hemet, Jungle Hunter and Swamp King Dred already and enough dust to craft 5 legendaries at most. Priest is my favorite class but I already have it golden and want to get every class golden (I'm still open to crafting Priest legendaries).I'm choosing between Open the Waygate, Sunkeeper Tarim, Awaken the Makers, Lyra the Sunshard, Unite the Murlocs, Kalimos, Primal Lord, Fire Plume's Heart, and Elise the Trailblazer. (I'm not going to craft the golden versions, I only made the cards golden here because they look cool.)

I do like Priest more than the other classes but I still like playing every other class somewhat (I dislike Druid the most though). I don't want to play deck that sucks but I don't want to play a boring one, thanks for the suggestions.

Bump

Play with rogue, cards like hallucination and the more hard to kill plant in the history is fun.

I'd go with Lyra, Kalimos, and Elise and then save the rest of your dust for future crafting (maybe a high-powered deck will appear next month and you'll need some cards to play it). Lyra is awesome in Priest and opens up a few ways to play (Silence, Inner Fire, Standard Control). Kalimos in Shaman is also very good and I've seen some cool builds with him in it. Elise just seems like fun and since most priest decks are more control oriented, she might be good in that as well.

 If you want to have fun, I recommend Open the Waygate. OTK Freeze is the funniest deck I've ever played but you'll probably get furious trying to do the combo vs. this aggro meta and fail a lot of times. If you want to win, I recommend Quest Rogue, search the best version and craft what you need.

Thanks for the help everyone. At this point I don't really want to craft two legendaries for the same class, so I need help deciding between Lyra and Makers for Priest and Kalimos and Murlocs for Shaman.

 Elise the Trailblazer is an alround fun card. If you like priest i would craft the priest quest, having a lot of fun with n'zoth priest.

Kalimos is better for standard, Murlocs are really strong in wild. Old Murk-Eye and Everyfin is Awesome got a lot of help from Un'Goro.  If you really want to go all out, craft Neptulon.

It's hard to choose for Priest.
Makers can be fun in a Thief Priest deck (including crystalline core). Lyra is inherently a Miracle card, so it is just as fun.
Priest in general is not an easy class to master fully tho. Maybe choose for the one that fits the cheapest deck.

For Shaman I'd go straight with Kalimos, no doubt.
Murloc flood looks boring to me and Megafin is excellent as threat and for more steam but honestly not exciting.

Lyra the Sunshard, from what I've seen, is very powerful.  I have her but she's not a good fit with my Dragon Priest deck (still the same list from Gadgetzan meta, playing in Wild), since I don't run a ton of spells.

If you have to choose between Lyra and Kalimos, i would go for Kalimos. 

So far I decided to craft Unite the Murlocs and Finja, the Flying Star and it's been both fun and good so far. Especially in wild with Everyfin is Awesome and Old Murk-Eye. Not sure what the other 3 legendaries are going to be yet but I'm leaning towards Elise the Trailblazer right now.

Does anyone have a list of core legendaries that I should craft first? I'm missing some really good legendaries and I'm not sure if I should craft one of those or not.