Hearthpwn

Guys I have dust only for one golden Hall of fame legendary. Which one do you think will see more play in wild ?

My feeling is Sylvanas, what do you think ? 

Definitely Slyvanas. They added some really strong deathrattle triggering cards this expansion.

Sylvanas

You silly man.  Get both in non-golden then you get your money back plus both cards. (if you choose your silly path which i don't recommend then look at this website's sylvanas and Rag golden cards... clearly Rag is prettier.

3200 divided by 2= 1600

1600 x 2= 3200 return investment (plus 2 cards) 

2 cards are better than 1 shiny one

Rag

Quote from Grayjudge >>

You silly man.  Get both in non-golden then you get your money back plus both cards. (if you choose your silly path which i don't recommend then look at this website's sylvanas and Rag golden cards... clearly Rag is prettier.

3200 divided by 2= 1600

1600 x 2= 3200 return investment (plus 2 cards) 

2 cards are better than 1 shiny one

Quote from Ginzo87 >>

Wut? Nope. The profit it's 0 in boh cases.

You craft 3200 gold = You get 3200 gold back

You craft both 1600 card  = You get 1600x2 gold back

(This assumming you don't own any of them and you want to keep them)

There is gold profit only if you previously owned any of these cards. If you craft them the only profit it's in the card themselves.

 

When can we dust them? Or does it do it automatically? Not sure how this works. But I have 2 regular copies. One of each

 Guys I forgot to tell you that I own both of them regular. Of course, the most profitable approach for dust return is to not craft them at all, but I want at least one because I like golden cards :)

We can dust them, and for OP, it's better to craft both normal if you don't plan on dusting the card afterwards as 2 cards are better than 1 shiny card. However, if you want to dust them, craft a golden legendary as you can dust that one for more dust than 2 normal ones, but if you do that it really doesn't matter which one you craft as won't have it anyway.

Sylvannss is stronger and will see play in more decks. Go for it!

Well id say go for sylvanas shes seeing a lot more play currently in wild than rag (prob a big reason for that is nzoth) and imo she looks great in golden.

Does it mean that, if you have both Sylvanas and Ragnaros in non-golden, you can dust them and craft the golden versions without any drawback?

If i understood well, I'll gain 3200 x 2 = 6400 dust after rotation? 

Guys, there's already this pinned thread:

http://www.hearthpwn.com/forums/hearthstone-general/card-discussion/186076-ultimate-dust-guide-for-hall-of-fame-cards

If you already have non-golden versions, you can't gain dust by crafting goldens and disentchanting them after rotation, but you can upgrade from non-golden to golden for 1200 dust each if you want to play golden in Wild.

Just to confirm one last time, I can net +800 by upgrading my non golden Ragnaros and Sylvanas, correct?  Craft goldens of each (-6400), dust non goldens (+800), get golden dust refund (+6400).  Right?

depends on what you mean by "net +800", in fact you lose 2400 dust because you would have gotten 3200 dust for your non-golden Rag and Sylv

again, it's all there already in the thread I linked to