Hearthpwn

Quote from RWBYSanctum >>

Quote from CypherBenkes >>

Quote from RWBYSanctum >>

Quote from CypherBenkes >>

Flame Leviathan really isn't that bad. I like using it quite a lot with Explosive Sheep, and I usually time it perfectly so both 2 damage AOE effects trigger at a good time. Flame Leviathan can also be really good against Zoo, especially when you consider sometimes only having enough damage to wipe some of the board. Draw FL when you can play Blizzard, so you have a four damage turn, or a six damage turn with Flamestrike.

Also, Malchezaar should be on this list in place of Moroes. Most people would say the same.

 Malchezaar? Why should he be on this list?  He gives you five extra legendaries to run with. Sure, he's basically a vanilla minion but does that matter when he can give you legendaries you can only dream of having? 

 You must be new here.

It's been discussed and mentioned, time and time again, that he puts minions in your deck that get in the way of when you need to draw removal or other cards. Enough of us already have practically every Legendary in the game, so why would I only dream of having cards when I can just wake up?

I feel like you just spit on with that line about Legendaries I can only dream of having, holy damn.

 Again, you're talking on the assumption that people running Malchezzar have so many legendaries. In that scenario then yes, it's a bad card. But for players who arent as lucky or are leas experienced, Malchezzar provides more legendaries that could be useful. 

Even if you have a lot of legendaries, Malchezzar still gives you some other legendaries you might not have. By the argument that you practically have all legendaries, then Elise Starseeker shouldn't see play since the Golden Monkey is worthless right? Sure it gets in the way of your removal draw, but consider that you can then replace some other cards with Removal or card draw. And it's not like the classes have little card draw:

Rogue: Sprint for 4 cards, FoK for 1 and Shiv for 1

Mages: Arcane Intellect for two

Paladin: Lay on Hands for 3,Divine Favor, Blessing of Wisdom, Solemn Vigil

Need I continue? 

I'm not saying Malchezzar is meta defining. I'm just saying it isn't terrible. Certainly Moroes and Medivh are far worse. 

(Yes I know so many people love Medivh. Point is unless you get him for free, itgives your opponent a chance to destroy it. And as a Rogue who runs double Sabotage, you essentially waste 8 mana. An 8 mana 7/7 with that ability is also pretty terrible. If it was 8/8 I think it wouldn't be too much bad. 

Moroes came at the wrong time, there were no meta with plenty of 1 dmg AoE as current one.

My heart goes with Anomalus,,, I have 3 of them...

Quote from DontFeedtheEmu >>

First off Moroes doesn't belong on that list. He is not great but he is ok. He is playable and there are enough unplayable Legendaries in Hearthstone to make a list of 10. 

Nat Pagle, doesn't see play after he got nerfed, but he used to see a lot of play. Enough to get nerfed. I still don't think he is that horrific if the meta ever slows down enough to play him again. 

10.) Bolf Ramshield. He did shine in one specific Taven Brawl but in constructed this guy turned out to have the text "Kill this minion for free by hitting the face" 

9.) Mimiron's Head. It does have some value because it is cool. But it is basically the mech version of Blood of the Ancient one. Pulling the combo off is just not going to happen very often. 

8.) Skeleton Knight. Yah, it's pretty terrible. Not a very strong play and it's one redeeming ability is a coin flip. 

7.) The Beast. If you every though "if only Anub'ark gave the opponent a minion..."

6.) Boogeymonster. I don't understand why this card was made. You don't understand why. Blizzard prolly doesn't even know why. 

5.) Hemet Nessingway. The game he hunted simply wasn't Big enough. lol

4.) Shifter Zerus. Everyone wanted him to work. He wasn't dismissed outright he praised as genius card design. Sadly, he just didn't work. 

The top three. These are legendaries that are not only bad. They actively help your opposed win the game. In pretty significant ways.

3.) Nat, The Dark Fisher. Your fishing for the wrong team buddy...

2.) Major Domo Executus. There was a Mage deck that ran this with limited success. For the most part card text reads "Set opponents health 8 win game next turn."

1.) Millhouse Manastorm. There is a special place in my heart for this guy. First legendary I ever got and he taught me a valuable lesson about the game when I lost on turn 2 against a Mage. No other Legendary in the game comes close to having the devastatingly bad effect of Millhouse Manastorm. 

honourable mentions to: Herold Volasjz, Bolivar Fordragon, Flame Leviathan, Lore Walker Cho, Mekgineer Thermaplugg, Anomalus, For Reaper 4000, Gruul, Mogor the Ogre, The Mistcaller, Wilfred Fizzlebang, and Bolivar Fordragon

Quote from CypherBenkes >>

Flame Leviathan really isn't that bad. I like using it quite a lot with Explosive Sheep, and I usually time it perfectly so both 2 damage AOE effects trigger at a good time.  

Master, how does one time Flame Leviathan?
I have tried him in many decks, but in the end, it simply doesn't work. Baron Geddon is better; same mana costs, exept you get to decide when it triggers...

Still haven't dusted him though, he was my first legendary card.

Quote from DMaster2 >>

Quote from AldoOP >

 Pretty solid analysis. But hey man, Fizzlebang is OP as all fuck. Try tapping into a 0 mana C'thun/Rag/hell anything over 4-5 mana & you're laughing!

 Fizzlebang sucks. If you can drop it and tap, it means you pretty much won the game. Any tempo and/or aggro deck will destroy you if you try to pull that play off.

Quote from BaronPanda >>

10. Elite Tauren Chieftain - Like any concert these days. Nice fireworks, but useless.

9. Illidan Stormrage - Oh, Illidan. What have they done to your stats.

There are niche legendaries and bad legendaries.

Sometimes you want to pull out a bizzare combo with Majordomo and Coldarra. Sometimes the card is pure fun to play an troll the opponent, like Cho. But you'd probably choose Boulderfist Ogre over The Boogeymonster or Gruul

Also, Hemet will never get dethroned!

You mean worst as in bad performance?

Then, by all means, boogeymonster.

Others like Cho, Darkfisher or Manastorm are good in niche contexts or deck.

But if by worst we are talking about bad design, then Dr. Boom must be the winner (don't even try with the best-in-slot story... He's just OP).

Quote from DMaster2 >>

Quote from Blue_Banana_whotookthisname >>

You mean any aggro/tempo deck automatically has 100% wr against any deck that tries to play anything after turn 8? Lol.

 No what i mean is that while you are busy spending 8 mana to play a 4/4 they will be busy destroying your face with their board/fireballs/etc... Same reason why Mistcaller see no play, the tempo loss is too big

Gonna throw Gazlowe in the mix, I don't think he saw very much play.  Plus his effect required a lot of set up.

Edit: I'd still take him over The Boogeymonster my god that card just gets it's poop pushed in.

Millhouse was the first legendary I ever got, and I prolly played him more then most people because of that. 

The main value in this card is teaching noobs like I was two things. First Legendaries are not always good, and free or cheap spells is tempo swing you generally don't come back from. Also a mage can KO on turn 2 if they have a hand full of free spells. lol. 

With the strength of cards now a 2 mana 4/4 isn't even insane without a huge drawback, and the drawback on Millhouse is huge. It is a somewhat strong tempo play or a play to one hundred percent loses you the game on the spot. Preeeeeeeeeety bad. 

Gazlowe is definitely a bad card if you ever want to win again, I had some fun with him though because the random aspect on any card can make it at least fun to play. Though random mechs tend to be a bit more boring then like burgle mechanics. 

Agreed. I think the idea was to save up spare parts and just dump your load and refill with hand full of mechs.  But people tended to use spare parts immediately or the following turn for some quick value.  The intentions were good, just unfortunate he didn't see any play.

Why no love for this guy? He cam cause crazy situations from Piloted Shredder, but those stats and a mirror effect? Way worse than Millhouse Manastorm, which CAN be a good tempo play at least.

Millhouse Manastorm is great out of the Portal or Piloted Shredder. There is no other use. But hes funny :)

The #1 worst legendary isn't even close, it is prince malchezaar.  In a well-built deck, prince malchezaar actively sabotages whatever your gameplan is.  He makes it harder to draw your removal, aoe, and actual win conditions.  And instead, he gives you a bunch of cards that weren't strong enough to put in your deck on their own.  I would rather put a literal blank card that I could never play in my deck over malchezaar, at least I would only have 1 dead card.

My full list:

10) Shifter Zerus

9) Maexxna

8) Mimiron's Head

7) Boogeymonster

6) Lorewalker Cho

5) Acidmaw

4) Nat, Darkfisher

3) Millhouse Manastorm

2) Majordomo Executus

1) Prince Malchezaar

Quote from tfink03 >>

Millhouse Manastorm is great out of the Portal or Piloted Shredder. There is no other use. But hes funny :)

Boogeymonster is not THAT bad in my opinion

It's a pretty unique effect and if I would have him I'll play him in ramp druid or so

Quote from Deadly_Pants2 >>

Boogeymonster is not THAT bad in my opinion

It's a pretty unique effect and if I would have him I'll play him in ramp druid or so

Skeleton Knight is pretty bad