Hearthpwn

Quote from hillandder >>

If Lorewalker Cho is 1/4 instead 0/4 will be great, the card is very weak because opponent don't trade nothing with minions.

Has anyone seen Anomalus been played in a deck ( Card from Elise doesn't count))?

Horrible card in my opinion.

Quote from JockyRhonson >>

Now let's flip this around and talk about the 10 BEST Legendaries!

10:  9:  8:  7:  6:  5:  4: 

3:  2:  

And now, the single BEST Legendary in the game (in my opinion, of course) is...

 

With Aviana, you are open to so many OTK combos. Who needs Charge when you have Aviana??? (rip charge)

A top ten legendaries without Sylvanas Windrunner, Tirion Fordring and Dr. Boom? What the heck is wrong with u?

Bolvar underrated, especially now that silence and BGH are rarely seen. 

I'm gonna repeat what many people have said with my choices, but hey, whatever.

When Old Gods first came out, I played against a Rogue with a mill deck trying out Nat the Darkfisher and honestly it didn't work out. It's kinda unreliable given that the effect only has a 50% chance of occurring, and in any other deck the effect is undesirable.

Millhouse Manastorm is one of those situational minions whose effect is really undesirable (especially against Mage) but is probably the best thing you'd get out of a card like Piloted Shredder or evolving a 1-drop. Certain classes and decks won't really benefit from the free spell turn but it's not really a card you'd want to run in a deck. Still wouldn't consider it useless.

Hemet Nesingwary's effect is too specific and his stats are pretty awful. I've only used him like once in one of those random card tavern brawls to counter a large beast the opponent played by chance.

The Boogeymonster's effect is not really justifiable. It's essentially a worse Gruul, which isn't too great to start with.

My bottom ten list would be as follows, taking account of minion, effect, and cost value (not in any particular order):

• Nat, the Darkfisher
• The Boogeymonster 
• Flame Leviathan 
• Anomalus 
• Hemet Nesingwary 
• Majordomo Executus
• Rend Blackhand
• The Skeleton Knight
• Mimiron's Head
• Nat Pagle

Quote from RWBYSanctum >>

Quote from CypherBenkes >>

Flame Leviathan really isn't that bad. I like using it quite a lot with Explosive Sheep, and I usually time it perfectly so both 2 damage AOE effects trigger at a good time. Flame Leviathan can also be really good against Zoo, especially when you consider sometimes only having enough damage to wipe some of the board. Draw FL when you can play Blizzard, so you have a four damage turn, or a six damage turn with Flamestrike.

Also, Malchezaar should be on this list in place of Moroes. Most people would say the same.

 Malchezaar? Why should he be on this list?  He gives you five extra legendaries to run with. Sure, he's basically a vanilla minion but does that matter when he can give you legendaries you can only dream of having? 

Quote from DoubleSummon >>

 Why dream of having? A competitive player got the right legendaries alreadyno need for 6 dead early game draws.

Quote from yossimills >>

Quote from DoubleSummon >>

 Why dream of having? A competitive player got the right legendaries alreadyno need for 6 dead early game draws.

I think this is the difference.  For seasoned players, it's useless (except in attrition/fatigue).  But for new players, it's the most exciting taster until they get their own legendaries.

I think Blizzard hit the nail on the head with this one.

top five + legendaries based on power

God Tier - Dr. Boom - Separate tier because I just don't even want to deal with this card lets get it out of the way

One. Pre (maybe even post) Nerf Yogg - I don't think any other legendary can swing games as hard as Yogg
Two. N'Zoth - Even though getting to the super late game is very inconsistent with the meta being aggro this guy owns late game so hard 
Three. Ragnaros - He is fast enough to be playable v aggro, and packs a sizable punch  v control
Four.  Tirion -Same deal but even better. He provides a destructive taunter v. aggro and super value control 
Five. Reno Jackson - Bane of aggro decks 
tied for Five. Leeroy Jenkins - Bane of control decks

top five legendaries based on fun 

One. Confessor Paletress - getting a random legendary when you hit hero power awesome 
Two. Lorewalker  Cho - Especially back in the day when he popped off of Shredder he added a lot of spice to the game 
Three. Elite Tauren Chieftain - He gives you the power of ROCK 
Four. Yogg - As salty as Yogg makes people. Come on. You know it is still pretty exciting to witness the power of madness, the Yogg fails at Blizzcon make it totally worth all the salt, now that you can insta purify Yogg. That was hilarious 
Five. Jaraxxus - You know you shit yourself a little the first time you saw this card, and the hero turned into Jeraxxus OBLIVION

Quote from DoubleSummon >>

Quote from yossimills >>

Quote from DoubleSummon >>

 Why dream of having? A competitive player got the right legendaries alreadyno need for 6 dead early game draws.

I think this is the difference.  For seasoned players, it's useless (except in attrition/fatigue).  But for new players, it's the most exciting taster until they get their own legendaries.

I think Blizzard hit the nail on the head with this one.

 Blizzard confirmed it being the design behind the card, rather than being a replacement for elise starseeker

It can be refered as a well designed card since it's purpose is well done(what you are saying)

On that way of thinking a top legendary doesn't necessarily means he is a bad card same for millhouse for example he is suppoused to be a fun card

Haven't opened many of those other ones, but Flame Leviathan was probably one of the most disappointing to open. Like it wasn't even that fun to play just for laughs. At least Millhouse is silly fun, it's like giving your opponent a Yogg on turn 2.

I remember frantically opening GvG packs for Dr. Fucking Boom and having to craft him cause RNG gods decided to have me pull two Flame Leviathans instead.