Hearthpwn

How has no one mentioned Troggzor the Earthinator yet? O.o

He's not even good in Arena :/

Quote from scorpyon >>

Quote from Zence >>

How has no one mentioned Troggzor the Earthinator yet? O.o

He's not even good in Arena :/

 I'm going to assume you're being serious (and this isn't a bait).
Personally I find Troggzor to be an amazing card - though as with some of the others, it needs proper set up to achieve it's momentum correctly. Obviously, drawing this card when you're topdecking and staring down a board full of minions is less than ideal.
But against an empty table it has great value, being able to summon a replacement (if being disposed of).

Of course, this is just opinion and others may differ. Granted. ;-)

Quote from scorpyon >>

Quote from Zence >>

Quote from scorpyon >>

 

 Yeah I'm serious. I get that he is great value, but he doesn't actually help you if you're behind, more like a win more card.

 Yeah, agreed that he's not a "pull you back from defeat" card, certainly. Though I think he is still a good card for "even" play (where neither player has the upper hand).

 

Quote from arrumph >>

I think the worst legendaries are the ones that are not only unplayably terrible, but super-boring. These five aren't even worthy of being called legendary:

#5: The Beast. It's like Core Hound, but with an enemy 3-drop inside.
#4: Flame Leviathan. A War Golem that sometimes blows up your board. Great.
#3: Gruul. A very expensive Shade of Naxxramas without stealth. Bonus: It dies to BGH!
#2: Hemet Nesingwary. Needs no introduction.
#1: Maexxna. Yes, she's worse than Hemet. Emperor Cobra + 5 health + 3 mana = how is this a legendary?

5. Genzo

4. Flame Leviathan / Dreadscale (could have been decent cards in Warrior)

3. Mogor

2. Nat the Darkfisher

1. Hemet

My vote goes to Rend Blackhand: The single most situational card in the entire game.

IF Gruul is that bad, whats left for this one The Boogeymonster

I would point out that Cho is actually good for some fun with adventures, and also great to test cards with friends

Manastorm is somewhat playable in lets say Pirate Warrior, it a decent coin or 2 drop, and sucks every other time

List: 1# The Boogeymonster this is worst than an alrdy bad CLASSIC CARD

2# Majordomo Executus Worst Deathrattle ever

3# Nat, the Darkfisher 50% chance of a card for ur opp for 1 extra life???

4# Hemet Nesingwar this is worst than an alrdy bad CLASSIC CARD that isnt even a legendary

5# AcidmawYeah sure CONTROL HUNTER FTW, worst concept ever

Worth mention:

Nozdormu

Madam Goya

Mayor Noggenfogger

Quote from scorpyon >>

His power and presence on release - as you mention - was indeed overshadowed by Dr Boom who was quite rightly considered vastly overpowered for some time. I'm surprised he was never really nerfed or dealt with actually - but that's another thread entirely! Heh!

Playing Lorewalker Cho almost always gets you at least one spell from your opponent. I'm tempted to craft one as an anti-Mage and Miracle Rogue play. 

Quote from Johnny_Cr >>

Quote from scout1515 >>

Millhouse Manastorm is awesome if you can play it turn 2 or coin it in turn 1. What's the worst your opponent can do?

Pyroblast + Pyroblast + Fireball + Fireball. kappa

Quote from Loubillion >>

Imo, every legendary in the game, no matter how bad they are, have a room somewhere, a niche to fill, and have synergy with other cards.

So my list would only consist of Gruul and The Boogeymonster. Design wise, they serve no purpose, they are just stats. Balance wise, they are reverse-powercreep, they are the worst cards for their cost, for any class, any deck.