Even though it's a token i've always thought treant was a minion type but Waste Warden doesn't target all of them only minion families. I understand this but does anyone else think that interaction should work?
my original post says minion type which they are all the same type and waste warden only hit 1 when there were 6 on board
They don't have a type, though.
If it works on Silver Hand Recruits that's honestly a bug because those don't have a type. The synergy cards reference the cards' NAME, not their type.
Treants should be given a tribe. They're getting benefits of a tribe without any of the cons. Waste warden should be able to work on them. It's only a matter of time before they update treants as a tribe, I'm sure.
Waste Warden should also damage copies even if they don't have a minion type but they are actually the same type of minion. For instance i tried waste warden on the 3 1/3 Warders that Magtheridon summons and it only targets 1. These kinds of things need to be changed since they clearly dropped the ball on this one. Or change the text of the card and make it hard to justify using.
Even though it's a token i've always thought treant was a minion type but Waste Warden doesn't target all of them only minion families. I understand this but does anyone else think that interaction should work?
Google search: Is Hearthstone free to play?
It should, as cards like Treespeaker clearly target them specifically but Waste Warden can't.
They should just go out and add the "Treant" tag to all treant created by any card.
Treant should just become a real tribe.
The only question would be to add the tag to Amalgam summoned from Hench-Clan Hag in standard.
(Card link didn't work for this one)
Or Nightmare Amalgam in wild now.
Tag says "All" but they currently don't count as Treant (which of course isn't in the actual card text either)
This. It's not a tribe, but they're clearly making it one, so they may as well just do it.
Waste Warden works against Silver Hands which are also not a tribe
I find it confusing, especially for new players. It would make sense to kill treants, but because they do not have a tag yet it doesnt count.
I think blizzard should give all treants a tag.
Always expect the unexpectable!
I think not, because they already have the same name; Treant.
The same goes for Silver Hand Recruits. They don't need a "silver hand recruit" tribal tag. And they shouldn't, as they're just humans with training.
I think it should work and they should just add the treant tribe. At least the new 5 mana spell summons beasts as tokens. So it works against them
The Card's NAME is Treant, not it's tribe. They don't have a tribe. I believe Flik will destroy all your treants even if they have different art.
my original post says minion type which they are all the same type and waste warden only hit 1 when there were 6 on board
Google search: Is Hearthstone free to play?
The problem is, technically Ancients and Saplings (Living Roots) are Treants as well, but adding a Tag to the Ancients would be a nerf.
It should actually work, just not the way you are thinking. Technically, treants are elementals.
I believe it'd be a buff, since you could then go ahead and play the ancients in your treant deck.
They don't have a type, though.
If it works on Silver Hand Recruits that's honestly a bug because those don't have a type. The synergy cards reference the cards' NAME, not their type.
I don't think so. Flik specifies it destroys all copies of it. Not all things with the same name.
If they have different art, they are different cards, and Flik doesn't hit them all
Flik destroys all cards with the same name like the slimes from Sludge Belcher and from Mire Keeper.
https://www.reddit.com/r/hearthstone/comments/e8xrrt/flik_skyshiv_kills_different_slimes/
That's also the reason why Flik could destroy the mirror entity spell by targeting the tokens(before they patched it).
Treants should be given a tribe. They're getting benefits of a tribe without any of the cons. Waste warden should be able to work on them. It's only a matter of time before they update treants as a tribe, I'm sure.
Waste Warden should also damage copies even if they don't have a minion type but they are actually the same type of minion. For instance i tried waste warden on the 3 1/3 Warders that Magtheridon summons and it only targets 1. These kinds of things need to be changed since they clearly dropped the ball on this one. Or change the text of the card and make it hard to justify using.
Google search: Is Hearthstone free to play?