Hearthpwn

Tried this deck ( Just to précise I'm not a beginner and was getting good results with an evolve deck with mutate,  but without sea giant and broomsticks and some other differences) . 

Trying this "legend" deck for several hours in gold 10 standard and I'm utterly crushed by every class. I don't remember a single win. Maybe one 3 hours ago, can't tell. 

Priest manage to counter easily the deck with the 2/6 taunt and khartuth, mass wipe spell, resurrection spell etc etc 

Warlock just keep using fire plague / rain of fire/ twisting neither / school spirits / flame breather on my board each time I manage to get ahead 

Warrior destroy my boards with brawl / the legendary minion setting health to 1 + dealing one damage when dead etc etc 

Paladin just get rid of the minions with the 2 damage on enemies spell or if I manage to get strong minions, spell equip a 1/4 weapons setting health to 1 , goodbye the strong board. ( And he blocks easily with the spell 8 health + 8/8 taunt twice) 

Shaman usually depends on the initial draw of the weapon / cage match 

Mage and Hunter prevent the evolving of the board with their goddamn damage all minions for 2 or 3 damage when the hero is attacked. the hunters have a lot of option to quickly boost weak minions and deal lot of damage without even caring for my board. And the mage usually have spells to ruin the board, at least to chain freeze it when he has low health point until using a broken shit like yoga saron and bam you lost the game. 

Do I even need to mention rogues? 

Oh not all hope is lost, at least I do fairly good against Druids trying to get survival of the fittest as quick as they can without even caring for their early board .  Wow. 

Well to me this deck is weak, too easy to counter for almost every class. I watch tons of vids and I know how to play the deck btw. So either it's weak or I'l seriously unlucky to go like 10 loss in a row... 

Edit : Another game another defeat against a mage. 

3 damage secret wipe out my early weak board, I manage to build a strong one, he summons the 2 damage per secret played minion, plays 3 secrets in a row, my 7 minions are dead. I'm left with 2 cards in hand ( lightning bloom and broom) no way to draw unless I get a draw minion, A 6/6 dragon and some other minions on his side doing damage and his spells destroying the few minions left I'm trying to evolve ( totems and weak things since u lost pit masters + hate on the strong board kill and can't draw the duplicates) and then I die. Can't see what I do wrong except choosing a bad deck? 

I really think that Revolve is an overlook. It can give you a win without even playing the Knuckles.

I opted for x2 Serpentshrine Portal and x2 Tour Guide instead of novice and sea giant. Tour guides a nice little 1 cost + totem summon to drop before boggspine.

I went from Gold 10 to Platinum 6 in one straight line, have tried two days in a row but can't seem to go further. I have replaced both Sea Giants for Revolves because it helped me get rid of some buffed stuff, still can't crack Platinum 5.

Deckwise I would cut , Prize Vendor and Novice engineer for Stormstrikes and Serpentshrine portals. Good luck in your games!

I managed to cross the Platinum 5 barrier for the first time before I made these changes, I'll try those and see how further I can go. Thank you!

Deck worked well. Got to legend with it today, thanks. From empirical experience, you can expect about 1 in every 10 games to be an utter defeat, where you won't draw your weapon or Cagematch Custodian until it's too late, or not at all (anyone care to do the math?). Apart from that, it's pretty consistent. About 50-50 against the super aggro DH. Super consistent against Priest and Paladin in current meta. Almost sure loss against warrior, unless you manage to keep a board by forcing and countering Brawls, Bladestorms, etc.

Some tips:

• Careful with 1-cost evolves (including your totems): you can get a Doomsayer and kill your own board.
• Don't mulligan Boggspine Knuckles away unless you already have Cagematch Custodian.
• DO mulligan Lightning Bloom. The deck is useless without your weapon.
• Your board is everything, but you can make use of the deathrattle-shuffles as a backup plan, should the game come to late game, such as Kargath Bladefist, Archspore Msshi'fn or Zixor, Apex Predator.
• DON'T END YOUR TURN in a rush after evolving! Some of your evolved minions may have charge or rush, and this mistake can cost you the match.
• Animated Broomstick is a great card for clearing the board after a strong evolve.
• I would feel comfortable replacing Sea Giant for something else (not sure what yet). It doesn't seem to add a lot of value: if you play it with a great board, it's redundant; if you play it out of tempo, it's useless...

Okay, an update. I have replaced both Sea Giants for Instructor Fireheart and a Bogstrok Clacker, and I can say that the deck has since become a lot stronger.

Sorry I haven't responded! I agree that Sea Giant is replaceable. The cards I would look to swap in are Surguing Tempest, Serpentshrine Portal, Stormstrike, or Bogstrok. Novice Engineer and Prize Vendor are also probably replaceable for those cards.

Hope you enjoyed the guide :)