I have crafted what I feel like is the best Murloc Paladin list. My goal was to counter priest and win mirrors. I believe this deck is fully optimized to be the best and the stats do not lie. I went 27-6 with this deck on my way to legend.
I have played +1500 games of murloc pally. I have come to the conclusion u only need 1 divine favor, hydrologist, and rallying blade.
I believe that against control you always keep seer if you CAN! Meaning you have a 1 drop and no coin and it wont put you behind. Fungal daddy op.
If there is enough interest i will post a guide
Thanks for looking and good luck out there
P.S this deck is 40% against lock so if you see a lot of lock just switch kings for second breaker.
As promised here is the mulligan guide
Always keep chum, tidecaller, inquisitor
Keep seer if you have a 1 drop vs. control
Mulligan hard for 1 drops if you go first