Hearthpwn

Garbage as every basic and classic paladin card. Maybe if it dealt damage back to the minion that attacked your hero, but right now it's a garbage failed design

Way too easy to counter. Only good in riidculously niche situations where the opponent can only attack with something that has high attack.

With Hydrologist being a thing now this wins me all the games vs exodia mages. the memes lol.

How so?
Fireballs kill you first.

Not if you have more than 6 health. 

I don't understand this card, when you kill the enemy with this secret it should end up I win(you hit the enemy first) or it is draw(both dies), but ends up losing why? The card didn't say the damage will be dealt on the enemy first... any explanation?

Your hero takes the damage, then the secret pops and equal damage is done to the enemy, THEN the game checks for deaths. The game sees you died first and as a result you're crowned the loser.

Me (the attacker) hits the enemy (with this secret) both have 1 hp, result is I lose. Why? I attack first HE took the damage FIRST then why I lose? your explanation isn't clear and doesn't make sense...

EDIT: ok I read in case of tie both loses, that explains it... but still I hit first game should ended when enemy have <=0 hp and the secret shouldn't pop cause he's already DEAD and game should be FINISHED...

just got this from swashburglar, used it and attacked with my hero, and nothing happened. then i lost the game cause i attacked a 6 attack minion. garbage

By far the worst secret in the game.

Considered one of the worst cards in the game for several reasons:

-No impact on board state

-Sits on your hand on the early game

-Can be played around and triggered by hero power or weak minion for an abysmal effect

-Has a small effect against most decks, very small window of use.

-Every other paladin secret can replace it for a better overall effect except sacred trial but that is an especific counter card against flood decks.

 P/s this is a very underserving ornament for the Paladin Christmas Tree! should be changed! ASAP! 

This should be changed into

When your hero got attacked, it is immuned and the opponent takes the damage he/she dealt to you.

Still bad not see play but at least it means fair 1 mana.

YAY now we have our sister from priest Purify to join the shitty card collection, only it lasts 1 year and this Eye for an Eye stinky shiit lasts forever in your classic collection you all! happy friday!

How about like that?

Secret: When your hero takes damage, deal all damage your hero took to the enemy hero at the end of his turn.

They should triple the damage of this secret.   Then it could be good against freeze mages who run pyroblast.

This card is useless in constructed.
My idea to buff this card: Can trigger on your turn.
With this change it would be possible to attack minion with weapon, take damage and deal the same amount to the opponent face. So when you play vs handlock  and attack his giant you also deal 8 dmg to warlock.

Old comment, but this is how secrets in general used to work. It was changed because it was too strong. 

This card won me two games in arena. No one expects it! A mage hit me with a Force Tank Max, then a hunter hit my face with a Savannah Highmane. I had lost board control at that point so without the extra 6-7 damage to their face I would have nearly certainly lost.

FYI, scales with spell damage.

"Let me think..."