Hearthpwn

Using this guy with Lyra the Sunshard has created some interesting games where Finicky Cloakfield ends up buying me a whole extra lyra turn!

This was in a netdeck I copied and it's just not very impressive to me. (But that's why you have to change netdecks up and make them your own.) I'm thinking of one of three options:

A) Swap for The Black Knight. The deck originally called for it, but I decided leaving Confessor Paletress in was a better idea, and that Toshley was a better choice than BK.
B) Put Holy Fire back in. It was originally a placeholder until I got the rest of the legendaries (this one called for Sylvanas Windrunner and Ysera besides the two previously mentioned); but when I consider that Toshley might hand you a card that grants a minion +1 hp, as opposed to a card that deals 5d and heals 5, the former doesn't feel as good. (Especially if your opponent has something to clear him immediately, like Shadow Word: Death.)
C) Find an alternative outside the last two. Which is why I'm thankful for this site.

deck probs has toshley for the big drop or the spare parts

This card just might be pretty good now thanks to the Paladin and Mage quests.

The card is a control card as spare parts really assist in that and so does having 7hp instead of 6 or 5 like most minions and that mana cost.

I might use this instead of Thaurissan on my mage... Good synergy with Antonidas and I feel like thaurissan is too slow for that build

Thinking about Toshley just makes me sad. He's cool and has a cool effect and wants to synergize with Archmage Antonidas soooooooooo badly but there just isn't a deck that really has room for him, particularly over Sylvanas Windrunner. Hopefully he'll one day find a home where he can truly shine.

Toshley is fantastic in Mech or especially Tempo Mage decks.  He's basically; Battlecry and Deathrattle: do something useful and put a Fireball in your hand.

He only has 1 less Attack than the vanilla Boulderfist Ogre, so he loses very little for his effect, and trades very well.  

yes.

Toshley is incredibly good in certain decks.  Piloted Shredder is a common, and although great, a gold version is a terrible trade for any viable Legendary.

You should regret your decision.

I know man.. and the minion that it poops out is gold too.  I also crafted gold Shredders, but I didn't disenchant a good Legendary to do it.  Ya gotta prioritize your dust. ;)

This card should see more play in Mage class with the new BRM card Flamewaker. His stats are pretty solid (kills popular minions like Emperor Thaurissan, Loatheb, Sludge Belcher ..) and the free spare parts will help.

yay! just got his golden card from an arena pack.

Obviously not a strong legendary, and certainly not a competitor to Sylvanas in most decks. Probably quite a few 6-drops that usually work out better for most decks also. Not convinced that Tosh is better than sunwalker for example.

However, the spare parts do make him better than Boulderfist. The -1 attack usually doesn't matter, and the spare parts sometimes do.

Especially stealth, rewind, reverse, and freeze can all be game-winning in the right circumstances.

I just had the pleassure of stealthing Chromaggius against an unlucky mage, and the next round I had 2x loatheb and 2x keeper of the grove in my hand (after using wild growth to draw an extra card), not to mention that sassy 6/8 body still on the board.

He would be awesome with just a small buff. 

I actually really like this card, post BRM at lest. Kills Thaurissan, Loatheb, Belcher and the Spare Parts are nice

Quote from plantlord98 >>

I actually really like this card, post BRM at lest. Kills Thaurissan, Loatheb, Belcher and the Spare Parts are nice

Still love him

Tried to build a Rouge deck uses spare parts... I don't think the spare parts would be just enough to use, while you still have to have a spell eating cards on board or in hand.