The Witchwood Guide
actually picked this one and it's quite potent not crazy broken but very good would pick as 1st treasure, hoping to get the hilt on the second pick for an insta win on last boss.
I just want to note that picking this does not guarantee later getting hilt, or vice versa. I found this out the hard way.
When you have the Hilt and the Blade in your deck, you get the Weapon automatically in your starting hand. It's more than OP!
There is some secret to this one? But what? If anyone else be reading the messages between battles, twas hinted that this weapon was to be rebuilt...
Get both parts ;)
I would say it's good, buuut I can't
If you get the hilt: http://www.hearthpwn.com/cards/77217-queldelar