Hearthpwn

12 dmg for 3 mana. Yea! Currently stone is super boring. Power curve has risen in all forms to boredom. Face, card draw, insane OTK combos etc.

Anyone remember when Fiery War Axe was OP - 3/2 weapon for 2 mana and needed tune to be 3/2 for 3 mana.
Yes, cards don't have to and should not be equal but difference is HUGE.

-D

Mistermath's Card Ratings for Voyage to the Sunken City:

8/10

Hey, you. Yeah you. Do you remember when Self-Sharpening Sword came out and everyone was afraid of a 3 mana weapon doing 10 damage to face? Or even Hooked Scimitar and its relatively fast 8 damage? Well, here comes the next 3 mana rogue weapon that will define aggro/tempo decks! Swordfish is obviously insane, as it's really not a condition at all to put super-efficient pirate cards that you were already going to put into your rogue deck, and it applies serious pressure to both aggro (by doing 4 dmg to opposing minions for 3 turns in a row, guaranteeing board control) and control (by Pyroblast+2-ing them on turn 3). 

Op card. Should have 1 less attack or durability.

The first weapon with a Beast tag?

I can already see how this weapon will be nefred from 2/3 to 2/2

This seems very good for the pirate archetype rogue is getting. With the new core set pirates and the new ones in this expansion, it should be simple to dredge a pirate for that extra damage. If its not a pirate, then its probably a spell that will draw rogue a pirate. Not broken, but not bad either for the cost.

Rustrot Viper += 1

Pirates probably still don't have enough support, but if it does then damn this is brutal.

12 damage for 3 mana... so we need weapon removal from now on in every deck. Got it...

So potentially 12 damage weapon for 3.  Not that bad, but I'm not sold on the mass pirates thing.