Hearthpwn

Pretty good card but one of the ugliest I've ever seen

Because it actually does nothing. You have to spend 2 mana and it doesn't affect the board, don't draw, it just don't help you in any way. All it does is help you win fatigue games, which honestly don't even happen these days. Like, even control x control rarely goes to fatigue. Not to say it's literally useless against anything but control and again it's only usefull if the game goes to fatigue for both players, which again, don't really happen these days. And even against fatigue you're probably better runing Prince Malchezar, at least it's a 5 mana 5/6 instead of a 2 mana do nothing. And when a card is worse than Prince Malchezar you know how bad it is...

http://imgur.com/a/DLWJq
I don't remember if it was during LoE or TGT. I've done some 12-0 before and after that (not many, about 10 in total) but this was the easiest one for sure. I didn't even have to think with just the right amount of early game, some Seal of Champions and Aldors, insane mid game with Dark Irons, Truesilver, Shredder and even Maidens of the Lake with Murloc Knight and Mukla's Champion and then the icing on the cake with double Sky Golem, Rag and Kraken.

Sorry but it will not. It's going to be like Kraken or Bog Creeper which are insane in arena but too weak for constructed exept in very specific (mostly meme) decks.

Bear  Trap has Ironfur Grizzly art but Polymorph: Boar isn't Huffer and Cat Trick isn't Jungle Panther. I think this card will have it's own new token instead of being emperor cobra...

Yeah, we (and the rest of the ladder, because there is a LOT of this deck on ladder) are all very lucky and you are the only unlucky guy. Are you Kripp or something?

The thing is you should have won already by turn 9, and if you didn't it's because you had an Onyxia in hand doing nothing the whole game. Just... no

I think you just don't know how to play the deck...

Will Hunter finally come back and be THE cancer class? It seems so with the quest, the 2-drop and now this...

Quote from lzboy >>

Only question i have , can it adapt itself?

Rogues uses fan to cycle when their hand is aweful and they don't have anything better to do. It's not in the deck because you plan on using it on an empty board. Also, some (actually a lot) of recent rogue decks don't even run fan. And I honestly fail to see how can Mimic Pod be better than fan, except if there are no aggro decks (and let us not kid ourselves).
I mean, I really don't think the comparison between grimy goons and discard makes sense honestly. The power of discard cards is bigger, the reward is better and it's more consistent because everytime you fail on discarding the right card the chances of you discarding the right card increases because you have 1 less card in hand. Also, It's not just that Zavas gains +2/+2, it also returns to your hand. It's like you draw a card, and that card gains +2/+2, and that's just broken. Also, Malchezar's Imp is also insanely good and it doesn't rely on RGN to work.
Oh, and don't forget Ice Lance will be Wild as well as Reno. So yeah, I don't expect Ice Barrier being run in anything and block >>MAYBE<< in some aggro freeze mage without ice lance if that's even remotely viable. And all the other secrets are thrash, so as much as Arcanalogist seems good because it's a 2/3 draw a card, having to run secrets and making your deck bad for that isn't worth. I say you go with your initial guts and throw it at tier 3.

In the end this is your list and it's just for fun, so just do whatever you think it's going to happen. This pessimistic thing is kinda cool, it's a different view from all the people saying every single new non-complete garbage card is going to be playable. I'm still pretty sure Zavas is going to see play in discard lock and though the deck itself may not be tier 1 I think it's at least going to be viable. Maybe the best Warlock deck because reno is rotating and Warlock doesn't have enough heal to run Control, but still maybe not tier 1.

Quote from LordPikachuStarscream >>

Volcano is obviously one of the worst cards in the entire game. Why would you list a 5 mana Spreading Madness with overload (2) as tier 1? 

Because it can't hit face, turning it in an insane AoE. The only problem is that's in Shaman so maybe it'll not be used as much... If it was in a class that could run a control deck, Volcano would be insanely good. Still OK in shaman I guess, but I agree not tier 1.

But if you can't realize why not hitting face turns this type of effect from garbage to one of the best and most versatile AoE forms idk what to say...

I'm honestly sad about the feedback you're receiving. I recently post something in a random comment of a new card (I think shadow visions), but people here just overhype every single card that it's not obviously thrash and if you try to argue why a card is bad >>most<< (not all, but 80%?) of them just insult you for no reason.
Ok, so you predicted some cards wrong on Old Gods, but what people forget you put some cards that thought to be good or even great on bad tiers ans they turned out to be bad. TBH I think you're more accurate than at least 90% of people, who just say everything is good.

On the current list: I don't agree with all of them but it seems pretty good overall. I actually don't think Mimic Pod is very good. It's ok, but I still think the fact you don't get variety only hurts you, in every type of deck. and rogues actually don't like spending 3 mana and doing nothing on the board...
Also, Volcano. I mean, I agree it's good but probably not tier 1 because it's a shaman card. Warriors would love to play that over Brawl (if control warrior ever comes back). Priests also. But I don't see a control shaman honestly. MAYBE with the new cards (the new epic and legendary are pretty good), but I'm still pessimist about that. And I don't think it's good in midrange (even jade) because you remove your own board too and you don't plan on being losing the board on turn 5 as midrange shaman anyways. It's like why Tempo Warrior didn't run Brawl and Dragon Priests run Nova instead of Excavated (if even any of them) back in the day.
Finally, I think you're underestimating discard zoo. Sure Zoo is dead now, but that's because they gained >>nothing<< from gadgetzan while insanely powered cards were introduced. In Karazhan Discard Zoo was fine, and in Old Gods Zoo (not discard) was actually really good. What I'm trying to say is, a lot of cards are rotating out, zoo is bad now but doesn't lose much (outside of Imp Gang Boss) and Zavas is actually insane. What you have to understand is yes the discard is random, but discard zoo doesn't have a lot of cards in hand anyways and there's even a new card that discard (Lakkari Felhound, which I think is also good but only good) . You have too keep in mind we still have Silverware Golem and Malchezar's Imp, and with Zavas we're stacking incredibly good discard mechanics (when they happen), which increases the probability it happens.

All in all, I really admire the patience you have with people by the way you answer them when most of them are just rude to you. Don't let them discourage you! I said it before, but your guesses are a lot more accurate than most of the people here.