So I was dusting to try to have a solid Murloc paladin, when I managed to complete the base set to earn Old Murk-eye.
Then I went to play with the new deck to see at the end of the game, i earned another Old-Murk Eye.
I went back into my collection at the end of the game to confirm I got 2 old murk-eyes.
Also, my game kept telling me that there was something that could be dustable. I concluded this to be my second old murk-eye, but since murk-eye is a quest item, I can't disenchant it.
When I tried to queue up again, i got a hearthstone sprite error, and had to close the game.
When I opened the game again and went to my collection, i noticed that my second old murk-eye was deleted.
Even though Murk-eye is a quest item, do I have a claim for 400 dust for the errant second murk-eye?
even if it hadn't taken the 2nd one back you wouldn't have been able to dust it because it was spell bound meaning that you would have been forever stuck with it telling you that you could dust something that you couldn't actually dust
So I was dusting to try to have a solid Murloc paladin, when I managed to complete the base set to earn Old Murk-eye.
Then I went to play with the new deck to see at the end of the game, i earned another Old-Murk Eye.
I went back into my collection at the end of the game to confirm I got 2 old murk-eyes.
Also, my game kept telling me that there was something that could be dustable. I concluded this to be my second old murk-eye, but since murk-eye is a quest item, I can't disenchant it.
When I tried to queue up again, i got a hearthstone sprite error, and had to close the game.
When I opened the game again and went to my collection, i noticed that my second old murk-eye was deleted.
Even though Murk-eye is a quest item, do I have a claim for 400 dust for the errant second murk-eye?
No.
Have a great deck that's really, really cheap? Help the new players out
No, that was just a bug. You can't "claim" 400 dust.
nah, it was just a glitch. you did nothing to earn the second copy, and like you said. its a quest item...
Hey! Listen!
GENERATION 41: The first time you see this, copy it into your signature on any forum and add 1 to the generation. This is a social experiment.
It doesn't seem like you gained or lost anything at the end of this whole process. Why would you even have a claim for 400 dust???
Hey all F2P players out there! Try out my 100% free deck before trying to call this game pay to win!!!
ok, thanks. I just wondered how on earth I got a second murk-eye.
I lost the chance at disenchanting it for 400 dust since it is a duplicate legendary.
No, since original Old Murk-Eye is not disenchant-able.
No, you didn't. The game bugged out and showed you earning a quest reward twice, which it then corrected. You didn't "lose" anything.
Alright, thanks for the explanation. This is the second random problem I ran into in 2 months.
even if it hadn't taken the 2nd one back you wouldn't have been able to dust it because it was spell bound meaning that you would have been forever stuck with it telling you that you could dust something that you couldn't actually dust
http://www.hearthpwn.com/forums/hearthstone-general/general-discussion/47984-old-murk-eye-bug