Hearthpwn

I've extra dust to spare and I'm stuck between either Valeera the Hollow, classic Hogger, Uther of the Ebon Blade, or The Marsh Queen. I can't decide between these four. If you had to choose, one of them, with no context, which would you choose? I already have good decks I can build around these cards, or vice versa. I'd just like to make one of them but I am honestly stuck deciding.

I can't decide between these four. If you had to choose, one of them, with no context, which would you choose?

Personally, if you are dead set on crafting one of these, I would craft Valeera the Hollow. She's underrated. She is a great addition in all Rogue decks currently in Standard except Prince Keleseth Rogue, but lots of people seem to just look at her and think she is a waste.

If you are open to another opinion, though, don't craft any of these. Just wait until Kobolds & Catacombs releases, and wait for the meta to settle before you craft anything, because something from that expansion might better suit you after you see what you get.

With those choices, Valeera. 

Ahhh yeah that's true. I'll probably wait then, and if nothing suits my fancy then I guess I'll come back to these, lol. Thanks for the advice.

Sure thing, was glad to help!

I would craft keleseth or leeroy.

But out of those carnessa or Valeera. Hunter is a good cheap class so carnessa is good. If you have cards to make a strong rogue that uses veleera (like miracle rogue) craft her.

Hogger is trash.

The two death knights are both worth crafting eventually if you're loaded with dust, but never craft hogger

well..... these are pretty strange selections, but if you are set on these valeera is the best. Uther might be good in future xpacs, but the marsh queen is almost the epitome of terrible and hogger is also really bad. 

Wait till the expansion comes. Then wait at least 2 more weeks before crafting.

hogger and the marsh queen most likely won't get better in the future, so between the 2 deathknights i'd go with valeera having the highest potential. i would still wait, though which legendaries come up in the next few weeks

Depends on whether you like miracle rogue or control paladin better. Miracle rogue has been and always will be in the game. However strong. Control pally comes and goes but it has a strong core. If it ever becomes good again uther will be in it. 

I'm shaking my head at this thread. Save your dust, none of those are really worth spending dust on at this point in time.

If you want to make a card anyway because the dust is burning a hole in your pocket, don't listen to us -- craft the one that goes into the deck that you want to play the most. 

Valeera or Uther depending on which class you see yourself wanting to play.  Valeera could end up being a staple for some Rogue control decks in the future.  Uther will probably never be essential for any deck except OTK combo in Wild, but it's fun to play with.

Please check out this thread for discussing all your legendary crafting questions. 

Legendary Tier Crafting Guide