Hearthpwn

I think the main problem with number 6 is that it asks you to do so much. It's already incredibly difficult to find a saying that fits your class, and then that saying has to be able to be split roughly in half and still be cohesive by themselves. Then, you have to design a card to fit each individual half and spend ages trying to make them seem like cards that can stand on their own (As they should). Like, sure, you could do it, but there's so much effort required to do it well that I don't think it's worth it, especially considering how arbitrary the restriction is compared to something like Cost or Lines of Text. Sure, I managed to come up with something myself on the other page, but I think I got pretty lucky, since the words happened to fit really well, and I already had cards that kinda matched them.

Quote from Tomerick88 >>

Quote from PRKSlayer >>

Just a reminded that my class focuses on trying to accumulate or copy a single card and gains benefits from repeatably using one card during the whole match. Here are the Hero Power and Keyword. If you haven't seen my post, please check it out :)

               

                                                                     (still working on wording for keyword, suggestions are appreciated)

 I love the Nuts and Bolts challenge a lot, and even if it doesn't win I will still submit my matching card :P Here they are, I am very happy with Calm both thematically and mechanically. I'm mechanically happy with Storm, but it may be too wordy for a basic, so if I get feedback to trim it down I will try something different for Storm (but I have to introduce the 3 or more mechanic somewhere in the basic set). All feedback is appreciated, thanks :)

 Nice idea.  On storm you want 'you're' not "your".  It would be cool if you were rewarded for playing calm before storm in some way.

 

Quote from Tomerick88 >>

Quote from PRKSlayer >>

Just a reminded that my class focuses on trying to accumulate or copy a single card and gains benefits from repeatably using one card during the whole match. Here are the Hero Power and Keyword. If you haven't seen my post, please check it out :)

               

                                                                     (still working on wording for keyword, suggestions are appreciated)

 I love the Nuts and Bolts challenge a lot, and even if it doesn't win I will still submit my matching card :P Here they are, I am very happy with Calm both thematically and mechanically. I'm mechanically happy with Storm, but it may be too wordy for a basic, so if I get feedback to trim it down I will try something different for Storm (but I have to introduce the 3 or more mechanic somewhere in the basic set). All feedback is appreciated, thanks :)

 Nice idea.  On storm you want 'you're' not "your".  It would be cool if you were rewarded for playing calm before storm in some way.

Quote from Demonxz95 >>

Regardless, I do have 2 cards in case it does win. I think I'm a bit on to something here.

Been There and Done That both are part of the phrase "Been There, Done That" (someone gave me idea for that, I forgot what his name was but you know who you are), and I love that Been There's artwork is a portal or a vision of another place hence I've "been there". They both cost 4 mana and have very similar effects. You might ask "why 4 instead of 3?" when compared to similar cards (Arcane Intellect, Thoughsteal). They might be underpowered at 4, but when I compared Been There to Zola the Gorgon and Duplicate, 4 seemed about right.

I now also have 3 cards with 3 or more lines in them so I only have 1 spot left for Deceptively Simple.

Fun fact: The character that appears in Done That is the same character as the Classic Legendary:

(In case you can't tell, I suck at names, especially original names)

BTW, when a challenge says "example cards" does that mean the showcased cards specifically or could it be the cards behind spoilers?

Quote from NOVEX0R >>

Question: I'm not sure, are we going to show 3 Basic cards and 7 in spoiler or just 3 Basic cards? 

Quote from Sinti >>

Quote from Demonxz95 >>

Quote from Demonxz95 >>

Regardless, I do have 2 cards in case it does win. I think I'm a bit on to something here.

Been There and Done That both are part of the phrase "Been There, Done That" (someone gave me idea for that, I forgot what his name was but you know who you are), and I love that Been There's artwork is a portal or a vision of another place hence I've "been there". They both cost 4 mana and have very similar effects. You might ask "why 4 instead of 3?" when compared to similar cards (Arcane Intellect, Thoughsteal). They might be underpowered at 4, but when I compared Been There to Zola the Gorgon and Duplicate, 4 seemed about right.

I now also have 3 cards with 3 or more lines in them so I only have 1 spot left for Deceptively Simple.

Fun fact: The character that appears in Done That is the same character as the Classic Legendary:

(In case you can't tell, I suck at names, especially original names)

Bump for feedback. I suppose having 2 cards with very similar effects in the Basic set isn't that good of an idea, and Done That might be stretching it in terms of Basic card complexity.

 

 

I like the phrase Been there, done that. It fits your class nicely. Been There looks fine, tho Done that might use a bit of a simplification, yeah. Also its probably a little too strong, even tho it doesnt look like it. I mean you dont even had to have played those cards in the same turn, this could result in some serious value, too much probably. Or even some weird combos/otks that players could figure out, dunno. It looks like it invites all kinds of dangerous situations. Definitely more than a basic card should create imho.

Kara Shellen: lol another 6 mana 4/8 ?:D But i do like the card, cool ability for the class and obviously good stats :)

---

Ok, im toying with this: Practice makes perfect :) Btw im open to suggestions for Perfect, hard to figure out what art to use on that one, the one i have is kinda cool i think, but im not too sure about it (especially since i cant rly center her, cause there is no more art to the left).

Also im starting to think that i will continue to rock the "Deals double damage to X." theme through out my entire class, i already have Z-00 K33-P3R in ONiK with "Deals double damage to Beasts, Dragons and Murlocs.". I kinda like the idea of it and it fits my class nicely too.

Quote from Sinti >>

Quote from Demonxz95 >>

Quote from Sinti >>

Quote from Demonxz95 >>

Quote from Demonxz95 >>

Regardless, I do have 2 cards in case it does win. I think I'm a bit on to something here.

Been There and Done That both are part of the phrase "Been There, Done That" (someone gave me idea for that, I forgot what his name was but you know who you are), and I love that Been There's artwork is a portal or a vision of another place hence I've "been there". They both cost 4 mana and have very similar effects. You might ask "why 4 instead of 3?" when compared to similar cards (Arcane Intellect, Thoughsteal). They might be underpowered at 4, but when I compared Been There to Zola the Gorgon and Duplicate, 4 seemed about right.

I now also have 3 cards with 3 or more lines in them so I only have 1 spot left for Deceptively Simple.

Fun fact: The character that appears in Done That is the same character as the Classic Legendary:

(In case you can't tell, I suck at names, especially original names)

Bump for feedback. I suppose having 2 cards with very similar effects in the Basic set isn't that good of an idea, and Done That might be stretching it in terms of Basic card complexity.

 

 

I like the phrase Been there, done that. It fits your class nicely. Been There looks fine, tho Done that might use a bit of a simplification, yeah. Also its probably a little too strong, even tho it doesnt look like it. I mean you dont even had to have played those cards in the same turn, this could result in some serious value, too much probably. Or even some weird combos/otks that players could figure out, dunno. It looks like it invites all kinds of dangerous situations. Definitely more than a basic card should create imho.

Kara Shellen: lol another 6 mana 4/8 ?:D But i do like the card, cool ability for the class and obviously good stats :)

---

Ok, im toying with this: Practice makes perfect :) Btw im open to suggestions for Perfect, hard to figure out what art to use on that one, the one i have is kinda cool i think, but im not too sure about it (especially since i cant rly center her, cause there is no more art to the left).

Also im starting to think that i will continue to rock the "Deals double damage to X." theme through out my entire class, i already have Z-00 K33-P3R in ONiK with "Deals double damage to Beasts, Dragons and Murlocs.". I kinda like the idea of it and it fits my class nicely too.

What do you mean another 6 mana 4/8? I haven't seen any others recently.

Practice looks very iffy. It would be too weak if it only lasted 1 turn, but preventing a minion from attacking heroes permanently might be a bit problematic. Perfect seems balanced when compared to Windfury (the card, not the keyword), though stacking 2 of them on top of each other might be a problem. By the way, you can center art better if you zoom it in/out slightly and you can move the image over more if you're okay with that.

I absolutely love the flavor as well. Spot on!

I did a 6 mana 4/8 and then i saw at least two other ppl do it after me and more now :D ahaha i know it's not like i "invented it", it's understandable ppl would eventually do this, since there is no 6 mana 4/8 in the game in the first place (well, one uncollectible), so that is a good cost-stats to go for in a custom class to make something "new". It's just funny to see more and more of em pop out, thats all :)

Why could be Practice problematic? Especially since my class is mostly about minion combat, so not like i would ever had a win condition where i could just let my opponents minions sit there, even if one or two of them wouldnt be able to hit face.

About the art for Perfect, yeah i tried to zoom in and move it to the right, but then you cant see her blades, which i think is a pretty important part of the art there, so thats why i decided to have it like this in the end. Btw i dont think casting Perfect on a same minion twice would quadruple the damage, i suppose technically it could, but lets assume it wouldnt.

Quote from ShadowsOfSense >>

So, completely random hypothetical question for you all that will almost definitely never need to be practically applied I hope but if there were two challenges which were tied for 3rd place, would you prefer that we:

A) Flip a coin to determine which challenge you have to follow (or some other suitable random binary choice selector).
or
B) Make it so you have to follow both challenges, so you have 4 challenges for the phase instead of 3.
or
C) Some other option - we're open to suggestions.

Quote from TrickyB3ast >>

These cards serve a lot of the challenges. I hope most of you know the new meme Do you know de way? :'(