Hearthpwn

@LockNeko You could word it "Has Lifesteal if the last card you played was a minion. Has Poisonous if it was a spell", though that would change the functionality slightly. He would have Lifesteal right away, and neither after you play a weapon or hero card. It would eliminate the ambiguities, though; a card can't be both a minion and a spell, so he wouldn't be able to have both at once.

Thanks to all the coments, after read you, i make some changes. I guess i will go with one of these as the are now. Any final thoughts?

Comments for everybody who posted after me:

@Hieii: This isn't worded properly but I can't think of any way to word this properly that would fit in 4 lines of text. Also the effect is not very original and as noted by Tox I already made a card similar to yours.

@RazorOfArtorias: Rare, though I don't like the base concept. I don't see the point of the deathrattle being secret since it doesn't really affect your opponent's decision making.

@The_Giratina: Too complicated, and the card doesn't fit the WoW universe.

@Prod: Upon looking at the card more closely I really like it. Even though it is good, it doesn't stand out from other card (which is why I must have missed it during my first global review). First art is definitely best. Would upvote.

@Shatterstar1998: I don't see this being played. Most of the time you would prefer your own minions to a 2/4 Taunt.

@TheProgenitor: Lord Stal is the most interesting but three times might be broken and fuck design space. I would reduce it to twice and raise the stats as a trade-off. Would upvote with those changes. I don't find the other cards interesting.

@Ozymandias: Thanks for feedback. Given other's feedback I still can't decide between the first three I posted though. Unfortunately I don't find any of your cards interesting from a gameplay level, their effects are all underpowered.

@Hererahreherheretc: The base concept is interesting but the effect is complicated for what it does, also Shaman is not a Grimy Goon class. I would make it deal a fixed amount of damage. Don't know if I would upvote yet.

And of course self-promotion:

Given the current feedback, Doom Shredder, Haunting Spirit, and Venomfang Totem seem to be overall equally preferred.

Quote from Hereharehere >>

Het all, thanks for those who gave me some feedback already but I'm still not sure of a best option.

The Giant Freak'n Clown is 10 cost as you need to lose heath first to reduce the cost. Then either attack with a slow minion (except Paly Charge guy), or lock/priest spells. Priest has the best potential for a mass reduction, but that doesn't seem to have a massive swing effect till atleast t5/6 then it's anticipated and is subject to losing lots of health first.

Old Crone was Trick or Traitors

but couldn't find a good image. If you've got a suggestion it would be great (rigght now, i'm blind from serching though the multitude of disturbing looking clowns there are out there D'':).

I like the theme for Vampyr Mercenary but wondering if it's op?

Do you think it's ok to say 'lifesteals' meaning when life is restored more than (0). Generally in hearthsstone (0) value is a non event? i believe.

 

Quote from CheeseEtc >>

Global review incoming!

NOTE: A lot of cards became dead links, so I can't evaluate them.

Cards I'd vote for:

Putricide's Monster by Zence (page 1) - This is ******** and therefore awesome. It could be neutral though.

Blood Mage by Novexor (page 2) - The 2/2 version.

Revenge Killer by Tox (page 4) - The 3 mana version.

The Razorhydra by Teknican (page 5)

Spectral Seeker by StegosauruxRex (page10) - The stats can be tweaked with but I'd say they're broadly right given the power of the card text.

Clever Girl by... oh wait.

Sadomummychist by Lathy (page 12)

Obvious Rager by MrUncreative.. wait

Hellish Valkyr by Cogito (page 13)

Cards I'd vote for with modifications:

Prince Tenris by Tox (page 2) - I would word it "the next spell you cast this turn" so it can only be used as part of a combo which is better vis-à-vis classes that have no business having powerful one-sided AoEs (Paladin, Druid, etc.). I still prefer Revenge Killer though.

Obituariy Parrot by DuhmyNate (page 9) - I love the card especially the art! However the wording is ambiguous, it should say "Deathrattle: Trigger the latest triggered Deathrattle" or something along this line.

Spooky Scary Skeletons by Otovent (page 10) - Nice meme, but underpowered as fuck. It could completely have vanilla stats.

Cards I won't vote for even with modifications:

The rest.

---

As for me, given the feedback, I'm down to these choices.

DOOM SHREDDER - Again, the meme card that some of you liked but that seems risky to me. Also I can't find any great art for this.

HAUNTING SPIRIT - A more 3spooky5me version of my previous Vindictive Sorcerer. I've also increased the damage deal to 6. I feel it was too weak otherwise.

VENOMFANG TOTEM - Again, there were some disagreements on the stats. My original version was a 4mana 0/4.

BLOATED MUR'GHOUL - A more 9spooky11me version of my previous Suicide Bomber. Also made a Murloc. Comparable to Volatile Elemental but the effect is more immediate. It's a Murloc so it's especially useful in Murloc decks for early board control but can also be used as a control tool in non-murloc decks. [Alternative stats: Deal 2 damage to a random enemy (so it has a chance to hit the hero). I'm not sure whether restricting the effect to minions might make it OP]

In addition to those, here are 2 new cards I didn't show before:

ARMORED NERUBIAN - Based on the card I submitted for the Worgen class special competition. Armored Nerubians gives Druid a form of hard removal that is consistent with its class identity. [Alternative stats : 3mana 2/4]

FLYING WITCH - A simple and flavorful idea based off Fire Fly. I strongly hesitate for the stats though, I have 3 variants in mind:

• 1mana 1/2, spawns 1/2 weapon (current version)
• 2mana 2/1, spawns 2/1 weapon
• 1mana 2/1, ADD a 1mana 2/1 weapon to the hand. As a rogue, adding cards to hand might actually be better.

Which is best ?

 

Quote from MrUncreative >>

Weird week so far - got many ideas, but few that actually work out properly. Anyways:

Somehow i really like the weird little contrast between 'Dorian Greymane' and 'Darion Mograine'. Huh.

 

Quote from 0megaZ3r0 >>

Bumping my cards, again. Any thoughts?

 

• Hopeless Champion: you should probably word it as "if an enemy Hero card has been played" becuase Death Knight tends to refer to the tokens that Arfus and The Lich King produce. It's nice to see some anti-DK hero tools, but this seems WAY too powerful. Maybe make it lose Divine Shield. I also don't think DK heroes are too overpowering that they need a stronge counter.
• Leonel Bloodrage: Oooooh. Burgle and Weapon synergy? Sweet! Those parts of Rogue could always use some love, and this is a great way to provide it. However when compared to Leeching Poison (2 mana) and Blood-Queen Lana'thel (loses 2 mana's worth of stats), this a bit too potent. Thus, I suggest that you make it a 4/3 or 4/4. Additionally, the comma between "and" and "class" is not necessary.
• Bloody Executioner: I like the idea of providing a Lifesteal weapon, but this is a bit too strong when compared to Arathi Weaponsmith. I suggest that you bump it up to 2. Regardless, I'm not really a fan of providing Lifesteal/healing in Warrior since it's not part of its identity (Armor is).

Gah, I'm getting equal results for all of my cards...Your thoughts?

A new idea...